Veterans seeking jobs in state employment just won a major victory in the courts, with the cour ruling 5 to 4 in the Torres v. Texas Department of Public Safety case that states are not allowed to invoke sovereign immunity to block lawsuits by veterans who want to reclaim prior jobs with state employers.
Commenting on the background of the case, SCOTUS blog noted that:
The Supreme Court revives a lawsuit by a former Texas state trooper who says Texas violated federal law when it did not give him a new job upon his return from military service. SCOTUS rejects Texas’ argument that the lawsuit is barred by the doctrine of state sovereign immunity.
The Supreme Court itself also described the background of the case in the introduction to its opinion:
Petitioner Le Roy Torres enlisted in the Army Reserves in 1989. In 2007, he was called to active duty and deployed to Iraq. While serving, Torres was exposed to toxic burn pits, a method of garbage disposal that sets open fire to all manner of trash, human waste, and military equipment. Torres received an honorable discharge. But he returned home with constrictive bronchitis, a respiratory condition that narrowed his airways and made breathing difficult. These ailments, Torres says, left him unable to work his old job as a state trooper. Torres asked his former employer, respondent Texas Department of Public Safety (Texas), to accommodate his condition by reemploying him in a different role. Texas refused. So Torres sued Texas in state court to enforce his rights under USERRA. §4313(a)(3). Texas tried to dismiss the suit by invoking sovereign immunity.
Justice Breyer, writing the opinion and swatting away the idea that states can claim sovereign immunity when defending against a lawsuit authorized by Congress, said that:
“Upon entering the Union, the States implicitly agreed that their sovereignty would yield to federal policy to build and keep a national military. States thus gave up their immunity from congressionally authorized suits pursuant to the ‘plan of the Convention,’ as part of ‘the structure of the original Constitution itself.’”
So Texas could not act against Mr. Torres in the way that it did and then, when he sued in a suit specifically authorized by Congress, invoke sovereign immunity.
That’s a big win for veterans seeking jobs with the state after returning home from war not just because it helps Mr. Torres and thus is a symbolic win, but also because it gives the Congressionally-authorized lawsuit more teeth, which could mean that states will try harder to avoid acting a way that would give veterans grounds to sue under it.
Surprisingly and sadly, however, most of the court’s conservative majority dissented in the case, with Justice Thomas saying that the majority opinion rested on “contrived interpretations” of the court’s prior decisions.
Kavanaugh and Roberts, however, sided with the veteran, Mr. Torres, and against Texas. Regardless, its a big win for veterans and their employment prospects upon returning from war.
By: Gen Z Conservative, editor of GenZConservative.com. Follow me on Facebook and Subscribe to My Email List
Veterans Seeking State Employment Just Won a Big Victory in the Supreme Court
Veterans seeking jobs in state employment just won a major victory in the courts, with the cour ruling 5 to 4 in the Torres v. Texas Department of Public Safety case that states are not allowed to invoke sovereign immunity to block lawsuits by veterans who want to reclaim prior jobs with state employers.
Commenting on the background of the case, SCOTUS blog noted that:
The Supreme Court revives a lawsuit by a former Texas state trooper who says Texas violated federal law when it did not give him a new job upon his return from military service. SCOTUS rejects Texas’ argument that the lawsuit is barred by the doctrine of state sovereign immunity.
The Supreme Court itself also described the background of the case in the introduction to its opinion:
Petitioner Le Roy Torres enlisted in the Army Reserves in 1989. In 2007, he was called to active duty and deployed to Iraq. While serving, Torres was exposed to toxic burn pits, a method of garbage disposal that sets open fire to all manner of trash, human waste, and military equipment. Torres received an honorable discharge. But he returned home with constrictive bronchitis, a respiratory condition that narrowed his airways and made breathing difficult. These ailments, Torres says, left him unable to work his old job as a state trooper. Torres asked his former employer, respondent Texas Department of Public Safety (Texas), to accommodate his condition by reemploying him in a different role. Texas refused. So Torres sued Texas in state court to enforce his rights under USERRA. §4313(a)(3). Texas tried to dismiss the suit by invoking sovereign immunity.
Justice Breyer, writing the opinion and swatting away the idea that states can claim sovereign immunity when defending against a lawsuit authorized by Congress, said that:
“Upon entering the Union, the States implicitly agreed that their sovereignty would yield to federal policy to build and keep a national military. States thus gave up their immunity from congressionally authorized suits pursuant to the ‘plan of the Convention,’ as part of ‘the structure of the original Constitution itself.’”
So Texas could not act against Mr. Torres in the way that it did and then, when he sued in a suit specifically authorized by Congress, invoke sovereign immunity.
That’s a big win for veterans seeking jobs with the state after returning home from war not just because it helps Mr. Torres and thus is a symbolic win, but also because it gives the Congressionally-authorized lawsuit more teeth, which could mean that states will try harder to avoid acting a way that would give veterans grounds to sue under it.
Surprisingly and sadly, however, most of the court’s conservative majority dissented in the case, with Justice Thomas saying that the majority opinion rested on “contrived interpretations” of the court’s prior decisions.
Kavanaugh and Roberts, however, sided with the veteran, Mr. Torres, and against Texas. Regardless, its a big win for veterans and their employment prospects upon returning from war.
By: Gen Z Conservative, editor of GenZConservative.com. Follow me on Facebook and Subscribe to My Email List
This story syndicated with permission from Will, Author at Trending Politics
My Pillow Coupon Code = ILMF
Tap Here and Use It!
Calling All Americans! Patriot Fetch is Conservative Breaking News Headlines every day, all day. Go to PatriotFetch homepage for daily Conservative news or look below for the next hot story!
Read More Conservative News
“Special Needs Candidate”: Joe Biden Gets ROASTED on Tucker Carlson Segment [WATCH]
CA Business Folds Due To Crime Spikes And Moved To Alabama; Here’s What They Found When They Got There
Nightmares Lately? Ghoulish New California Law Will Give You One!
China is Silently Buying Influence in US Universities and Biden has Turned a Blind Eye
Wild: Pink Floyd Star Sounds Off on Slow Joe, Calls Him a War Criminal in Stunning CNN Interview [WATCH]
Joe Rogan Reveals The Truth About ‘Woke Twitter’ And How It’s A ‘Non-Spiritual Religious Cult’
Viral Video: A Black Family Has Filed a Massive Lawsuit Against Sesame Place Over This Performance
Over 250 People Rescued From Sex Trafficking By FBI
Hillary Clinton Spouting Off To Megan Thee Stallion About ‘WAP’ Made Twitter Drag Up The Infamous Hot Sauce Incident
Watch: No One Likes Pelosi! NYC Music Festival Proves It!
Biden Admin Being Squeezed In A Vice As Pressure From Threat Of Rail Strike Builds
Nancy Pelosi Threatens Britain’s US Trade Deal Over Its Brexit Negotiations With Ireland
Shocker! Trevor Noah Says Something That Makes Sense!
“You Haven’t Seen Anything Yet”: GOP Congressman Vows Investigation into Hunter Biden
Howard Stern Shoots Off Mouth, Rips Trump Supporters Again
Is this Why She Went to Taiwan? Watters Suggests Stock-Based Corruption at Root of Pelosi Trip
Hillary 2024? Hillary Finally Speaks on If She’ll Run Again [WATCH]
An Amazing Piece Of Our Nation’s History That Was Stolen Has Now Been Returned…And Will Soon Be On Public Display
What’s on Deck for the Congressional Charity Baseball Game? Protests!
This School District is Promoting “Genderqueer” Identities and Teaching Children that Heterosexuality is “Oppressive”!
Did ‘Woke’ Whoopi Goldberg Just Say God Allows Murder????
“Literally Save Our Democracy”: Slow Joe Biden Rambles about “Our Democracy” [WATCH]
Suggestion Made By Army For Soldiers Battling Inflation Gets Ripped By Lawmakers
United Airlines to Launch Futuristic ‘Electric Air Taxis’ to Fly Customers to the Airport for Just $100
Breaking! R.Kelly Offered To Pay $1 Million To Hide Evidence
Go on the Cruise of a Lifetime, for a Lifetime!
Town Shoots Down Planned Parenthood Request For Permit; Here’s How The Abortion Mill Responded
TRAGIC: 14-Year-Old Boy Accused of Killing His Missing 10-Year-Old Stepsister
Video Captures Bill Clinton Unconscious at NFL Game
TikTok Video Reveals Massive Amount Of Shocking Material Being Taught To Preschoolers