Fifth Circuit Federal Judge Andrew S. Oldham reversed course for courts and the government when he ruled on Friday that America’s social media platforms, platforms such as Twitter and Facebook (Meta), do not have a “freewheeling First Amendment right” to censor people on their platforms.
Specifically, Judge Oldham ruled against a lawsuit challenging HB 20. HB 2o was a bill pushed by Texas Governor Gregg Abbott which prohibits those social media platforms that have over 50 million monthly users from censoring people’s speech based on their political viewpoints. The text of HB 20 provides that:
The legislature finds that:
(1) each person in this state has a fundamental interest in the free exchange of ideas and information, including the freedom of others to share and receive ideas and information;
(2) this state has a fundamental interest in protecting the free exchange of ideas and information in this state;
(3) social media platforms function as common carriers, are affected with a public interest, are central public forums for public debate, and have enjoyed governmental support in the United States; and
(4) social media platforms with the largest number of users are common carriers by virtue of their market dominance.
The rest of the bill then goes on to provide the specifics of what companies are affected by the legislation and the definitions for the different relevant terms.
Judge Oldham, ruling on the bill in a way that was not expected by most court watchers, as they expected him to find the bill unconstitutional or contrary to Section 230, said:
“Buried somewhere in the person’s enumerated right to free speech lies a corporation’s unenumerated right to muzzle speech. Today we reject the idea that corporations have a freewheeling First Amendment right to censor what people say.”
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton celebrated his victory in the court and success in maintaining the bill in a post on Twitter in which he said:
“I just secured a MASSIVE VICTORY for the Constitution & Free Speech in fed court: #BigTech CANNOT censor the political voices of ANY Texan.”
Adding more context to the ruling and the victory for the right, Fox News reported that:
NetChoice, a nonprofit group representing Meta in the challenge against the Texas law, said in a statement they are “disappointed” with the decision. “We remain convinced that when the U.S. Supreme Court hears one of our cases, it will uphold the First Amendment rights of websites, platforms, and apps.”
Friday’s ruling created what is known as a “circuit split,” since the eleventh circuit struck down a similar social media law in Florida. A circuit split generally increases the likelihood of the Supreme Court taking up a case.
But while the ruling could, if eventually upheld by SCOTUS, mean that Trump has a route back to getting onto Twitter once again and sending the left into a tizzy with his hilarious jokes, it appears that he might not do so, as he has instead stuck mainly to boosting his social media platform, Truth Social. Writing about it on Wednesday, Trump said:
“Truth is doing amazing, the most engaged social media platform anywhere on the Internet! And now businesses who want to sell their great products to REAL people—not BOTS!—can buy localized ads on TRUTH via Rumble Ads.”
Whether he ends up back on Twitter or not, however, the ruling is something of a vindication for Trump, who was booted off of social media following the events of January 6th and then filed a class-action lawsuit in July of 2021 against those companies, claiming:
“We will achieve a historic victory for American freedom and at the same time, freedom of speech. We are demanding an end to the shadow-banning, a stop to the silencing, and a stop to the blacklisting, banishing, and canceling that you know so well.”
That end might not have been effectuated by his lawsuit, but Judge Oldham’s ruling means that the end Trump desired could be a reality if SCOTUS rules Texas’ way.
By: Gen Z Conservative
Yuge Win for Trump, Conservatives: Federal Judge Rules Big Tech Has No “Freewheeling Right to Censor”
Fifth Circuit Federal Judge Andrew S. Oldham reversed course for courts and the government when he ruled on Friday that America’s social media platforms, platforms such as Twitter and Facebook (Meta), do not have a “freewheeling First Amendment right” to censor people on their platforms.
Specifically, Judge Oldham ruled against a lawsuit challenging HB 20. HB 2o was a bill pushed by Texas Governor Gregg Abbott which prohibits those social media platforms that have over 50 million monthly users from censoring people’s speech based on their political viewpoints. The text of HB 20 provides that:
The legislature finds that:
(1) each person in this state has a fundamental interest in the free exchange of ideas and information, including the freedom of others to share and receive ideas and information;
(2) this state has a fundamental interest in protecting the free exchange of ideas and information in this state;
(3) social media platforms function as common carriers, are affected with a public interest, are central public forums for public debate, and have enjoyed governmental support in the United States; and
(4) social media platforms with the largest number of users are common carriers by virtue of their market dominance.
The rest of the bill then goes on to provide the specifics of what companies are affected by the legislation and the definitions for the different relevant terms.
Judge Oldham, ruling on the bill in a way that was not expected by most court watchers, as they expected him to find the bill unconstitutional or contrary to Section 230, said:
“Buried somewhere in the person’s enumerated right to free speech lies a corporation’s unenumerated right to muzzle speech. Today we reject the idea that corporations have a freewheeling First Amendment right to censor what people say.”
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton celebrated his victory in the court and success in maintaining the bill in a post on Twitter in which he said:
“I just secured a MASSIVE VICTORY for the Constitution & Free Speech in fed court: #BigTech CANNOT censor the political voices of ANY Texan.”
Adding more context to the ruling and the victory for the right, Fox News reported that:
NetChoice, a nonprofit group representing Meta in the challenge against the Texas law, said in a statement they are “disappointed” with the decision. “We remain convinced that when the U.S. Supreme Court hears one of our cases, it will uphold the First Amendment rights of websites, platforms, and apps.”
Friday’s ruling created what is known as a “circuit split,” since the eleventh circuit struck down a similar social media law in Florida. A circuit split generally increases the likelihood of the Supreme Court taking up a case.
But while the ruling could, if eventually upheld by SCOTUS, mean that Trump has a route back to getting onto Twitter once again and sending the left into a tizzy with his hilarious jokes, it appears that he might not do so, as he has instead stuck mainly to boosting his social media platform, Truth Social. Writing about it on Wednesday, Trump said:
“Truth is doing amazing, the most engaged social media platform anywhere on the Internet! And now businesses who want to sell their great products to REAL people—not BOTS!—can buy localized ads on TRUTH via Rumble Ads.”
Whether he ends up back on Twitter or not, however, the ruling is something of a vindication for Trump, who was booted off of social media following the events of January 6th and then filed a class-action lawsuit in July of 2021 against those companies, claiming:
“We will achieve a historic victory for American freedom and at the same time, freedom of speech. We are demanding an end to the shadow-banning, a stop to the silencing, and a stop to the blacklisting, banishing, and canceling that you know so well.”
That end might not have been effectuated by his lawsuit, but Judge Oldham’s ruling means that the end Trump desired could be a reality if SCOTUS rules Texas’ way.
By: Gen Z Conservative
This story syndicated with permission from Will, Author at Trending Politics
Calling All Americans! Patriot Fetch is Conservative Breaking News Headlines every day, all day. Go to PatriotFetch homepage for daily Conservative news or look below for the next hot story!
Read More Conservative News
Horrible: Veteran NYC EMT Murdered in Horrific Stabbing Attack
TikTok Video Reveals Massive Amount Of Shocking Material Being Taught To Preschoolers
Two Of Indiana’s Major Employers Just Came Out Against State’s Abortion Ban
Rep. Matt Gaetz Denies Rumors DeSantis Will Run Against Trump and Insists They Are ‘On the Same Side’
CNN Anchor Attempts To Give Top Democrat Senate Candidate Multiple Opportunities To Support Limits On Abortion…Here’s What Happened
BOOM: Gun-Toting Grandma Blasts Away Creepy Perv Exposing Himself to Her Granddaughter
Comedy Fires Back After Minnesota Cancelling of Chappelle
“Cosmic Level Embarrassment”: Bongino RIPS Biden DOJ, AG Garland for Placing Lives At Risk by Refusing to Do This
Brandon’s America: New Poll Has Eye Opening Results
Watch: Four Dead Including the Gunman Who Set Up a Death Trap
Legendary Canadian Balladeer Gordon Lightfoot Dead at 84
Insanity Continues: The Congressman that Slept with a CCP Spy Uses Anti-FBI Anger to Push for Gun Control
OOF: Lyin Liz Warren Continues to Make a Fool of Herself Attempting to Defend, Dodging Tough Questions about Student Debt Forgiveness
Open Border, Gun Laws, Abortion, Oh My! Hot Debate Between Abbott and O’Rourke
Biden Calls, Thanks Coast Guard Hero That He Is About To Fire!
Irate George Soros Blows Top In New Op-Ed Reveals Plans For Funding Leftist DAs
Nope! Maryland School Hires Teacher That Formerly Advocated for Black People To Burn the Country to the Ground
(VIDEO) Man Arrested After Rushing from Line and Grabbing Queen’s Coffin
Watch: While We Continue To Deal With Skyrocketing Inflation, This Town Isn’t Feeling the Strain
ANTIFA Teacher Who Was Handed $190,000 by School after he Indoctrinated Students Seen Enjoying Beers and Bike Rides
Sen. Ernst Says She Was ‘Shocked And Appalled’ During Border Visit; Here’s What She Saw
(VIDEO) Amber Heard Just Won’t Stop Trying to One-Up Depp
Derby-Winning Jockey Gives Glory to God After Thrilling Win
Don’t Like the Speaker on Campus? Kill Him, Suggests Wayne State Professor Steven Shaviro!
Geoffrey the Giraffe Makes a Comeback Just in Time for Christmas
WATCH! A Tossed Cup o’ Joe Just Might Help Unravel This Decades-Old Case
Disgusting DOJ Official That ‘Forced’ Date To Touch Genitals Learns His Fate…It’s A Miscarriage Of Justice
LOL: Fired Brian Stelter Gives Humiliating Eulogy for His Own Program, Struggles to Hold Back Tears [WATCH]
BREAKING: Queen Elizabeth II Has Died After 70 Years of Service
Alabama Woman Arrested for Making Club a Drive-Thru After Argument With Her Boyfriend