A Florida accident that resulted in the deaths of three people has sparked a serious response from Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy. Following the tragedy, Duffy issued an ultimatum regarding commercial driver licensing rules for states. The accident involved Harjinder Singh, an illegal immigrant from India, who reportedly hit three individuals while illegally maneuvering his tractor-trailer on a Florida turnpike on August 12. Duffy noted that Singh’s commercial driver’s license was initially issued in California and that he previously held one in Washington State. There was also mention of a traffic stop in New Mexico during which Singh’s vehicle was not taken out of service.
Duffy is giving the states 30 days to ensure compliance with regulations or face potential loss of federal funding from the Motor Carrier Safety Assistance Program. “We are not going to tolerate states that don’t comply with the rules that come from this department,” Duffy stated during a press conference. This statement underscores the seriousness of maintaining safety and adherence to laws designed to protect all road users.
In the wake of the crash, investigations revealed that Singh had failed both English proficiency and road sign tests. The office of California Governor Gavin Newsom defended the issuance of Singh’s license, insisting that it complied with federal law and shifting blame towards the Trump administration. A spokesperson for Newsom’s office expressed frustration: “This is rich. The Trump administration approved the federal work permit for the man who killed 3 people — and now they’re scrambling to shift blame after getting caught.” This exchange highlights the political tension surrounding this incident.
Homeland Security Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin has contradicted Newsom’s office regarding Singh’s work permit timeline. McLaughlin stated, “False. Harjinder Singh is in the United States illegally and his work authorization was rejected under the Trump Administration on September 14, 2020. It was later approved under the Biden Administration on June 9, 2021.” This back-and-forth illustrates the complex interplay of policy and accountability amid a tragic accident.
New Mexico officials have contributed to the response by asserting their compliance with federal regulations concerning commercial driver’s licenses. Michael Coleman, a spokesman for the governor, expressed confidence: “New Mexico’s top priority is the safety of its residents and visitors, and we are confident that our state laws for commercial driver’s licenses (CDLs) are fully compliant with federal regulations.” He noted that New Mexico requires an English test to ensure drivers are knowledgeable about road signs, demonstrating efforts to uphold safety standards. Coleman also referred to the claims about enforcement as potentially relating to a small number of roadside incidents involving out-of-state drivers, reflecting the national nature of the trucking industry.
Washington State is also looking into how Singh managed to obtain a commercial driver’s license. The investigation reflects a broader concern about safety and the vetting process for those who operate large commercial vehicles. This scrutiny is timely, as Duffy emphasized, “This is about keeping people safe on the road. Your families, your kids, your spouses, your loved ones, your friends.” His statement encapsulates the ripple effect that incidents like this can have on communities, stressing the imperative for thorough and vigilant licensing compliance.
This situation raises critical questions about the responsibilities of states in regulating commercial driver licenses, particularly concerning those with precarious immigration statuses. As federal oversight tightens, states must evaluate their processes and ensure they are adequately enforcing safety regulations to prevent similar tragedies in the future. The dialogue around Singh’s case shines a light on the need for accountability within both state and federal frameworks. The stakes are high, and the consequences of inaction can be devastating.
"*" indicates required fields
