Officers at U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) are now required to consider the positive contributions of immigrants applying for citizenship. This shift, outlined in a memo issued on August 15, is part of a more comprehensive approach toward evaluating applicants. Specifically, it emphasizes that applicants should be seen as active, responsible members of society rather than merely assessed for a lack of misconduct.
The memo states, “Becoming a naturalized U.S. citizen means being an active and responsible member of society.” It encourages officers to look beyond past behaviors and instead focus on positive traits that reflect good moral character (GMC). USCIS officials are instructed to conduct a “holistic assessment” of each applicant’s conduct, which includes adherence to societal norms and contributions to the community.
While serious violent crime convictions have traditionally disqualified applicants from citizenship, the memo broadens the scope of disqualifying behaviors. It now includes issues such as drug use and multiple convictions for driving under the influence. Officers will also evaluate conduct that, while not illegal, may be seen as inconsistent with civic responsibility, including “reckless or habitual traffic infractions” or aggressive solicitation.
USCIS spokesman Matthew Tragesser highlighted the importance of this approach, stating, “U.S. citizenship is the gold standard of citizenship — it should only be offered to the world’s best of the best.” He noted that this change aims to bolster the integrity of the naturalization process and ensure that new citizens embrace American culture and demonstrate good moral character.
Moreover, officers are encouraged to consider additional factors such as community involvement, caregiving roles, educational achievements, stable employment, and tax contributions. The memo asserts that GMC assessments should reflect a “genuine positive assessment” of an applicant’s contributions to their community.
In summary, the memo from USCIS introduces a new framework for evaluating citizenship applicants that prioritizes positive contributions alongside moral character, indicating a significant change in how the agency approaches naturalization. This revised perspective could have lasting implications for those seeking the privilege of U.S. citizenship.
"*" indicates required fields
