US District Judge Amir Ali, appointed by President Biden, has made a significant ruling that blocks President Trump from cutting billions in foreign aid. This decision reinforces the authority that Congress holds over appropriations. The ruling came on a night when the administration faced a deadline for spending that was set to expire at the end of September.
Judge Ali’s ruling is clear: the Trump administration must comply with existing appropriations laws as they stand. He argued that there was no justification to ignore the expectation that Congress’s appropriations must be followed. Specifically, he noted that the administration could not choose to forgo spending about $4 billion of the $11.5 billion that Congress approved for foreign aid for 2024. The judge emphasized that the Trump administration is bound by law to follow the appropriations set forth by Congress unless those laws are changed.
This decision isn’t the first hurdle for the Trump administration regarding foreign aid. Earlier this year, Judge Ali intervened to block a freeze on foreign aid contracts imposed by Trump. Following Trump’s executive order that temporarily halted foreign aid for 90 days, Secretary of State Marco Rubio provided guidance to pause spending. Judge Ali previously stated that halting foreign aid could cause “enormous harm.”
As the White House prepares to appeal Judge Ali’s ruling, spokesperson Anna Kelly made the administration’s stance clear: “President Trump has the executive authority to ensure that all foreign aid is accountable to taxpayers and aligns with the America First priorities people voted for.” This echoes a sentiment held by many who support Trump, as they believe that government spending should reflect the will of the American people.
The administration’s fight to reshape foreign aid continues as it grapples with judicial decisions affecting its authority. Judge Ali’s ruling stresses the importance of accountability in spending, a point that resonates deeply in today’s political climate. The expectation is that the legal battle will continue as Trump’s team seeks to regain control over foreign aid decisions and expenditures.
In summary, this ruling from Judge Ali underscores a significant legal principle: the separation of powers and the role of Congress in overseeing budgetary matters. The implications of this case extend beyond immediate funding concerns, reflecting a broader struggle between the executive branch and the judiciary over enforcement of appropriations laws. The ongoing appeal will be a critical development to watch, as it not only affects foreign aid but also sets a precedent for future interactions between the branches of government.
"*" indicates required fields
