Fox News continues to maintain a striking hold on the cable news landscape. Their dominant position is evident when comparing their ratings to those of competitors like MSNBC and CNN, both of which struggle to keep pace. This dominance extends into the conservative news space, where one outlet, Newsmax, is taking a stand.
According to reports, Newsmax, led by Christopher Ruddy, has filed a lawsuit against Fox News in southern Florida. The lawsuit accuses Fox News, owned by Rupert Murdoch, of monopolizing the conservative news market and undermining its competitors. “Fox has sought to protect and expand its monopoly power in the Right-leaning Pay TV News Market by engaging in a suite of anticompetitive behaviors,” Newsmax’s attorneys stated in the legal filings. They argue that “Fox’s longstanding and ongoing practices have harmed and will further harm competition and consumers in the United States.”
The specific allegations against Fox News are serious. CNN reported that Newsmax claims Fox has instructed cable distributors not to carry competing conservative outlets. Further, the lawsuit mentions that Fox allegedly imposed extra fees on distributors who dared to carry these competing networks. Additionally, there are claims that Fox has constructed barriers within carriage deals, effectively preventing other channels from even trying to compete.
Ruddy remarked that Newsmax could have become a more successful business had it not been for these alleged practices of Fox News. “These tactics constitute unlawful restraints of trade and flow directly from Fox’s unlawful monopolization of the Right-leaning Pay TV News Market,” the suit claims. “Fox may have profited from exclusionary contracts and intimidation tactics for years, but those days are over,” Ruddy insisted.
Compounding the drama, it has been reported that Newsmax claims Fox employed private investigators to gather information on top executives at their network. “But for Fox’s anticompetitive behavior, Newsmax would have achieved greater pay TV distribution, seen its audience and ratings grow sooner, gained earlier ‘critical mass’ for major advertisers and become, overall, a more valuable media property,” the lawsuit asserted.
Fox News did not hold back in its response to these accusations. A representative stated, “Newsmax cannot sue their way out of their own competitive failures in the marketplace to chase headlines simply because they can’t attract viewers.” This shot highlights the network’s confidence in its position within the media landscape.
Ruddy countered these claims during an interview, asking, “Then why did they spend so much time throughout the years blocking and suppressing us?” His response underscores the contentious nature of this rivalry, one steeped in allegations and competitive maneuvers.
As the situation unfolds, Newsmax aims for monetary damages alongside a cessation of what they allege to be Fox’s monopolistic practices. The case serves as a significant moment, shining a light on the challenges faced by conservative media outlets in a landscape currently dominated by a single player. Whether the courts will rule in favor of Newsmax or uphold Fox’s practices remains to be seen, but the implications for the conservative media space could be profound.
"*" indicates required fields
