Cuomo’s Campaign Analysis: A Closer Look at the Odds and Dynamics
Andrew Cuomo’s efforts to regain a foothold in New York City’s political scene have met a resounding lack of support in the betting markets. After receiving an endorsement from outgoing Mayor Eric Adams, Cuomo’s odds to win the 2025 mayoral race remained stagnant at just 5%. This positions him far behind Democratic socialist Zohran Mamdani, who boasts a commanding 92% likelihood of victory, according to estimators on the prediction platform Polymarket.
Cuomo is not the only candidate vying for attention. Republican Curtis Sliwa, though trailing significantly at just 1%, showcases how fractured the opposition has become. A recent tweet aptly captured the current sentiment: “Cuomo should drop out and endorse Republican Curtis Sliwa.” This sentiment highlights a growing belief that Cuomo’s presence may hinder rather than help the anti-Mamdani vote.
Polling Data Paints a Clear Picture
Recent polling trends align with the stagnant betting markets, revealing Mamdani’s dominant position. A Quinnipiac survey from early October indicates he leads with 46% support, leaving Cuomo at 33%, while Sliwa holds 15%. The enthusiasm levels among Mamdani’s followers are particularly telling, suggesting that he will likely engage more voters on election day.
“The numbers changed but the contours of the race haven’t,” noted Mary Snow, assistant director of the Quinnipiac Poll, emphasizing that while Cuomo gained some support from Adams’ backers, it hasn’t been enough to narrow the gap. Mamdani’s backing is solid among younger voters and Democrats, with over 60% support from that demographic, positioning him favorably as turnout approaches.
Cuomo holds experience as an asset, with 73% of voters acknowledging it, along with narrow advantages in specific voter segments. However, this experience does not convert into momentum in the race against Mamdani, whose appeal seems to resonate more broadly with the electorate.
Failed Expectations of an Endorsement
Mayor Adams’ endorsement aimed to reshape the political landscape post-indictment but ultimately failed to energize Cuomo’s campaign. After the announcement, Polymarket’s odds remained unchanged, signaling that even high-profile endorsements can fall flat if the underlying conditions of a race remain unfavorable. Cuomo’s positioning as a centrist alternative contrasts sharply against a backdrop of polarized politics, yet his past issues continue to cast a long shadow.
During a recent debate, Cuomo faced pointed questions about his past conduct, illustrating the challenges of overcoming a tarnished reputation. His retort to Mamdani regarding allegations of misconduct lacked the force needed to shake off voter skepticism and remains part of his continuing struggle to reclaim trust.
The Math Doesn’t Favor Cuomo
Analyzing the numbers further reveals an uphill battle for Cuomo. Polling data from Gotham-AARP indicates Mamdani with 43.2% support, while Cuomo sits at 28.9%, and Sliwa at 19.4%. The potential for a tighter race does exist if Sliwa were to exit the contest. In a hypothetical scenario without Sliwa, Mamdani’s lead tightens but still maintains a slight edge, creating complex conditions for a comeback.
Cuomo recognizes this challenge, labeling Sliwa a “spoiler.” However, Sliwa has rejected that characterization, asserting his place in the race without reservation, further complicating Cuomo’s self-cast narrative of a viable “unity” candidate.
Time is of the Essence
With election day rapidly approaching, calls for Cuomo to withdraw are amplifying, particularly among those who fear a Mamdani-led city. Mamdani’s odds remain consistently strong, hovering around 88% to 94%, indicating a dominant position that shows little sign of faltering as the election nears.
Demographic analysis suggests Mamdani holds support among younger and more progressive voters, while Cuomo finds a stronger base among older individuals. While the older voting bloc is reliable, consolidating that support could prove elusive without Sliwa stepping aside.
Stephen Graves of Gotham Polling encapsulates the situation succinctly: “If the contest narrows to two leading candidates, the 50-plus electorate — by far the most reliable voting bloc — will likely determine who becomes the next mayor of New York City.”
The Broader Political Landscape
The ideological divide in this race is noteworthy. Mamdani’s progressive platform includes aggressive policies like rent freezes and taxes targeting the wealthy, alongside controversial stances regarding international relations that are not typically connected to local governance. Cuomo, in contrast, positions himself as a seasoned politician able to navigate contentious waters between several competing interests.
Yet, this strategy has not stirred sufficient voter interest or momentum in betting markets. Cuomo’s bid appears trapped in a cycle of polemics, appearing credible on paper while remaining ignored in practice.
Potential Outcomes Ahead
Unless a significant change occurs — such as Sliwa withdrawing from the race — Mamdani is on track for a clear victory. The numbers favor him, showcasing his solidified base and the splintering of opposition. The provocative suggestion that Cuomo align himself with Sliwa carries weight in understanding how the dynamics of this race could shift but requires significant cooperation that seems unlikely to materialize in the final days leading up to the election.
"*" indicates required fields
