Recent polling suggests that Governor Kathy Hochul faces significant challenges as she gears up for reelection. A poll commissioned by Congresswoman Elise Stefanik’s campaign reveals that Hochul’s support is wavering, particularly among independents, a crucial voting bloc. This poll indicates that if elections were held today, Hochul would narrowly beat Stefanik by just 5 percentage points, garnering 48 percent support compared to Stefanik’s 43 percent.
The insights from the poll shed light on a deeper vulnerability. When poll respondents were made aware of Hochul’s alignment with far-left candidate Zohran Mamdani, who is vying for New York City mayor, Stefanik gained a lead. In this scenario, 46.4 percent of those surveyed favored Stefanik, while Hochul trailed closely behind at 45.9 percent. This shift in voter sentiment underscores the impact of political affiliations on electoral prospects.
Landon Wall, a pollster from Grayhouse, analyzed Hochul’s political status and described her position as “deeply vulnerable.” He noted, “Kathy Hochul’s coalition is historically fragile: soft support from her own voters, significant growing appetite for change, and her endorsement of politically toxic Zohran Mamdani collapses support among Independents.” This perspective points to an emerging trend—the electorate’s demand for a departure from the status quo.
Moreover, Hochul’s hold on her own party appears shaky. In a primary scenario, she only received 43 percent support, with a notable 28 percent still undecided and another 15 percent indicating a preference for other candidates. Wall highlighted the difficulties this presents, stating, “A sitting governor unable to secure majority support from her party shows the historically weak position Hochul is in entering 2026.”
Even as Hochul grapples with these internal party dynamics, Stefanik has garnered a strong presence among New York Republicans. Though yet to formally announce her candidacy, she is expected to secure the GOP nomination without opposition. Notably, she positioned Hochul as “the worst Governor in America,” a sentiment that underscores the growing discontent among voters regarding Hochul’s governance.
Stefanik’s critique extends beyond mere political strategy. In her statements, she portrayed Hochul’s alliance with Mamdani as a desperation move, arguing, “It is now crystal clear why Kathy Hochul bent the knee to the Communist Antisemite running for Mayor of New York City because she desperately needed to shore up her own party.” This statement captures the urgency felt by Republican strategists as they seek to capitalize on Hochul’s perceived weaknesses.
On broader governance issues, Stefanik accused Hochul of exacerbating a crisis in affordability that burdens everyday New Yorkers. “Kathy Hochul has destroyed New York State, creating an affordability crisis with the highest taxes in the nation,” she charged. By linking her campaign narrative to economic hardships, Stefanik paints Hochul not just as a politically vulnerable opponent, but as a leader failing to meet the basic needs of the people she serves.
The 2026 election in New York will also see the fallout from Hochul’s 2022 victory where she secured 52.9 percent of the vote against Republican Lee Zeldin. The changing political landscape since then indicates a rising caution among Democrats, especially with a decline in high-profile endorsements and support from critical voters. Recent reports show that New York has 5.86 million registered Democrats, but the increasing skepticism among independents is alarming for Hochul’s campaign.
In summary, the polling data reveals a precarious position for Governor Hochul, who is fighting not just against a potential challenger in Elise Stefanik, but also an electorate that is growing restless. The implications of this polling, combined with observable shifts in party support, suggest a need for Hochul to reassess her political strategy as the 2026 election approaches.
"*" indicates required fields
