Rep. Nancy Mace has raised significant concerns regarding the prosecution of child exploitation cases in Dorchester County, as outlined in recently obtained Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) documents. The figures are alarming. From 2019 to 2022, the South Carolina Attorney General’s Office, led by Alan Wilson, processed 385 warrants related to child pornography accusations. However, only 29 of these cases, a mere 7.5%, resulted in convictions. The stark reality reveals that 356 cases were dismissed outright, with not a single trial held.
Mace’s frustration is palpable. She stated, “We obtained FOIA documents showing South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson failed to prosecute p*dophiles in Dorchester County… WE WANT ANSWERS. NOW.” Her call for accountability underscores a pressing issue: the fate of vulnerable children in the community.
The internal records don’t merely highlight a lack of convictions. They paint a picture of an indifferent judicial approach to serious crimes. The report demonstrated a pattern of leniency within the AG’s office. Children who are victims of exploitation remain at risk, with many accused individuals still living in the community while their cases linger unresolved—an astonishing average of 740 days without resolution.
This is not just an isolated issue. The data reveals an operational inefficiency in the Attorney General’s Office that has led local law enforcement agencies to lose confidence in their ability to handle such grave matters. In light of this, the First Circuit Solicitor’s Office has requested additional funding to create a dedicated child pornography prosecution unit, separate from its normal budget, underscoring the urgency of the situation.
Mace did not shy away from expressing her belief that this negligence represents a betrayal of justice. “This data is appalling and indefensible,” she asserted in a statement. “When almost every single child predator case is being dismissed and nearly every conviction results in a slap on the wrist, it is a betrayal of justice and an active threat to Lowcountry children.” Her remarks stress the serious implications of inadequate prosecution and the consequences for public safety.
Amidst these revelations, Wilson’s office has pushed back against the criticism. They characterized Mace’s statements as “deceptive,” asserting that the numbers Mace referred to do not account for all case outcomes, including federal interventions. Yet, despite the pushback, the core issue remains unchanged: the apparent failure to prosecute effectively and the resulting danger posed to the community.
Wilson’s office provided a broader context by stating that, when looking back to 2014, Dorchester County did see a higher number of cases prosecuted. However, that does little to assuage concerns about the current landscape under his leadership, particularly when contextually analyzing the severity and number of dismissed cases during a critical period for protecting children.
This matter raises profound questions about the accountability of those in leadership positions responsible for prosecuting crimes against the most vulnerable members of society. As the community awaits answers, the statistics serve as a chilling reminder of the responsibilities placed on officials charged with safeguarding children. Mace’s urgent calls for clarity and action highlight the pressing need for change within the Attorney General’s Office, emphasizing that inaction remains an untenable option.
The road ahead will necessitate renewed commitment and a firm re-evaluation of how child exploitation cases are handled. Until those responsible are held accountable for failures in justice, the protection of children remains a critical, unresolved concern in Dorchester County. Mace’s continuous engagement on this issue may serve as a catalyst for deeper scrutiny and reform. As discussions unfold, the community rightly demands not just answers but substantive action to ensure justice is served for its most defenseless residents.
"*" indicates required fields
