The race for the New Jersey governorship is heating up as November 4 draws closer, and recent developments suggest momentum is shifting toward Jack Ciattarelli, the Trump-endorsed Republican candidate. For the first time in years, early voting trends show Republicans slightly outperforming Democrats in mail-in ballot returns. This is noteworthy in a predominantly blue state.
As reported by Michael Pruser at DecisionDeskHQ, Republicans have returned 46.8% of requested mail-in ballots, compared to 46.2% from Democrats. This slim lead of 0.6% is small but significant, hinting at rising enthusiasm among GOP voters as election day approaches. Given New Jersey’s historical trends favoring Democrats in early voting, this shift signals a potential tidal wave of support for Ciattarelli.
A pro-GOP social media account highlighted these trends, suggesting that Democrat Mikie Sherrill is feeling the pressure. As the account asserted, “🚨 UPDATE: Democrat New Jersey governor candidate Mikie Sherrill is reportedly PANICKING into the final stretch against Trump-endorsed Jack Ciattarelli…” Such messaging reflects not only the tightening of the race but also the intensifying scrutiny surrounding Sherrill’s campaign.
One major concern is Sherrill’s acceptance of substantial campaign donations from Pin Ni, a Chinese-American businessman with ties to the Chinese Communist Party. Records show Ni contributed $65,800 to Sherrill’s campaign, raising alarm bells among critics regarding foreign influence in American elections. Michael Lucci, a nonprofit executive focused on tracking foreign influence, stated, “The donor, Pin Ni, has an extensive history of assisting the CCP’s political warfare and influence operations upon the U.S.” Such accusations could play a critical role in how voters view Sherrill’s alignment with American interests.
Republican strategists interpret the shifting mail-in voting patterns as promising for their chances in New Jersey. Adam Geller, associated with Ciattarelli’s camp, noted that enthusiasm is on the rise among Republicans. “Clearly, it’s encouraging for Republicans right now… it could be a measurement of enthusiasm for the candidate,” Geller explained. There’s a sense that the landscape is ripe for a Republican challenger to finally break through after years of Democratic dominance.
Public opinion surveys also reveal tightening margins. Sherrill’s lead, once a comfortable 8.3 percentage points, has diminished to just 3.3 points, with many experts labeling the race a toss-up. Add to this the fact that Ciattarelli’s internal data suggests he may even be narrowly ahead, and the stakes become clearer for both candidates heading into the home stretch.
On top of these dynamics, Sherrill faces challenges related to her economic record. High property taxes and rising energy costs remain critical issues for voters, who are increasingly frustrated by a lack of actionable plans from her campaign. With no commitments from Sherrill to reduce these burdens, voters are likely to remain skeptical about her ability to provide real relief. In contrast, Ciattarelli is campaigning on a straightforward platform of tax reductions, regulatory reforms, and support for small businesses, appealing not only to traditional Republicans but also to disenchanted Democrats.
Although Democrats still lead in overall mail-in ballot counts—having returned 53,319 more than Republicans—analysts caution that this figure is rapidly evolving. Furthermore, the low return rate among independent voters, who total over 2.1 million in New Jersey, suggests they could ultimately sway the outcome. Currently, independents have only returned mail-in ballots at a rate of 9.32%, leaving their final decisions up in the air.
The final weeks of the campaign will be crucial, with both candidates planning major rallies featuring prominent political figures to drive turnout. Ciattarelli will enjoy the support of Donald Trump, while Sherrill is set to draw in Democratic heavyweights like Barack Obama. However, the controversies surrounding Sherrill’s foreign donations and her stance on pressing economic issues may overshadow her campaign efforts. “Business partners don’t feel comfortable to deal with a company that has a Chinese background because they feel sooner or later they’re going to have a government issue,” Ni himself acknowledged. This reluctance among potential supporters complicates her position.
Political experts suggest caution, highlighting that early voting numbers are volatile and subject to rapid changes. Yet the unusual and potentially significant rise in Republican mail-in returns cannot be dismissed. As election day approaches, the race remains dynamic, with every voter decision carrying immense weight. The final debate between the candidates may also serve as a defining moment leading up to November 4.
"*" indicates required fields
