President Donald Trump’s proclamation on October 9, 2025, marks a pivotal moment in the ongoing debate about Columbus Day and its place in American history. He reestablished this holiday, designating October 13, 2025, as a day to honor Christopher Columbus, described in his proclamation as “the original American hero” and a figure of immense significance in Western civilization.
For many Americans, Trump’s declaration comes as welcome news, especially for Italian-Americans. The president’s proclamation not only reaffirms Columbus Day’s status as a federal holiday, first established in 1934, but it also dismisses efforts to replace it with Indigenous Peoples Day, initially recognized by President Biden in 2021. “Those days are finally over,” Trump stated, referencing what he called left-wing attempts to erase history by criticizing Columbus’s legacy and removing his statues from public spaces.
Columbus’s 1492 voyage is framed in the proclamation as a courageous expedition that spread Christianity to distant lands. Trump emphasized Columbus’s faith, portraying him as a pioneer who dedicated the new territory to God—a move that aligns Columbus with the founding principles many Americans hold dear. The proclamation stated Columbus “set in motion America’s proud birthright of faith,” catering to a sense of nationalism while promoting an enduring cultural connection between the United States and Italy.
The response from Italian-American organizations, like the National Italian American Foundation (NIAF), was overwhelmingly positive. NIAF President Robert Allegrini highlighted the importance of preserving Columbus Day as integral to both Italian heritage and American history, citing the holiday’s historical roots and its role in fostering Italian-American pride. The foundation has been a long-time defender of Columbus Day, countering attempts to diminish its significance.
Historically, Columbus Day was established during a time of racial tension following the lynching of 11 Italian immigrants in New Orleans in 1891. President Benjamin Harrison’s 1892 declaration was aimed at acknowledging the contributions of Italian-Americans to the nation, a narrative that continues today through events like the New York City Columbus Day Parade, which celebrates Italian-American culture and contributions.
However, Trump’s proclamation has triggered criticism, particularly among Native American leaders and advocates. Former Navajo Nation President Jonathan Nez expressed concern that such actions regress respect for Indigenous peoples. Over 200 cities and several states have replaced Columbus Day with Indigenous Peoples Day, reflecting a significant shift in public perception. This friction underscores a broader cultural clash regarding how history is remembered and commemorated.
Despite this resistance, the fervor surrounding Columbus Day remains, especially within the Italian-American community. Trump’s acknowledgment of the holiday as a source of pride aligns with a larger narrative that celebrates American exploration and cultural identity. As opposition to Columbus and his legacy grows in some segments of society, supporters assert the importance of understanding the full historical context surrounding his expeditions.
In this ongoing discussion, the celebration of Columbus Day can be seen not just as a reflection of one man’s achievements but as a lens through which to explore the complexities of American history itself. While some argue for the recognition of multiple perspectives, advocates for Columbus see his holiday as a chance to honor an enduring legacy of exploration and adventure.
The struggle over Columbus Day epitomizes a larger cultural discourse within the U.S.—one that grapples with the intersection of identity, history, and values. Trump’s proclamation, with its emphasis on reclaiming Columbus’s legacy, serves as a reminder of the deep-seated connections many feel toward their heritage. It flags an ongoing debate: the need to balance recognition of all facets of history while celebrating cultural heritage and identity.
"*" indicates required fields
