The recent enthronement of Bishop Cherry Vann as the new archbishop of the Church in Wales marks a historical turning point for the Welsh Anglican church. At 66, Vann steps into this prestigious role as the first woman and the first openly gay individual to hold the position within the global Anglican Communion. This event, celebrated on November 8 at Newport Cathedral, encapsulates a progressive change in a long-established institution.
Vann’s journey to this role has not been without its challenges. Once the Bishop of Monmouth, she has spent over three decades in ordained ministry, culminating in a significant election process that required a two-thirds majority from the church’s electoral college. This vote, held in Chepstow, was pivotal, signaling a willingness to embrace change within a traditional structure. Her partner, Dame Wendy Diamond, who has stood by her side for 30 years, was acknowledged during the ceremony, emphasizing a personal aspect often hidden in church hierarchy.
Vann’s statement regarding her relationship with Diamond reveals the struggles faced by those in the church. “For years, we kept our relationship secret because I worried about waking up and finding myself outed on the front page of a newspaper,” she expressed. In her current capacity, she has the opportunity to redefine previous norms — a significant shift given the church’s past restrictions on same-sex relationships among clergy. Only in 2021 did the Church in Wales grant blessings for these relationships, showcasing an evolving stance, though the church still refrains from solemnizing same-sex marriages.
The ripple effects of Vann’s election have already been felt globally, as the Church of Nigeria announced its intention to sever ties with the Church in Wales in response to this appointment. The Most Reverend Henry Ndukuba, a prominent figure within the Nigerian Anglican community, labeled Vann’s election an “abomination,” emphasizing a profound ideological divide. This response echoes a historical pattern of pushback against changes in church doctrine concerning sexuality, a contentious issue that has remained divisive since the ordination of Gene Robinson in the U.S. in 2003.
Vann’s consistent rise through the church ranks, beginning with her ordination in Manchester shortly after the Church of England allowed female priests, highlights her commitment to leadership. She served as Archdeacon of Rochdale and, from 2020, as Bishop of Monmouth. Her experience positions her uniquely to navigate the complexities of leading a church that operates under increasingly progressive reforms — having already seen the ordination of women as priests and bishops in recent decades.
This momentum toward modernization can be seen as a natural progression amid the historical context of the Church in Wales, which has operated independently of the Church of England since 1920. With a recent advocacy for more inclusive practices, Vann’s election can be interpreted as part of an institutional evolution. Nonetheless, the internal tensions between progressive and conservative factions remain palpable. As attendance has steadily declined, the church grapples with diverging opinions on the best way to connect with younger generations.
Supporters claim that Vann’s visibility promotes credibility, especially for a church eager to engage with the youth. However, critics warn that moves away from historical doctrine may cause confusion and a perceived weakening of the church’s core message. Vann’s candid approach to her personal life places her at the center of these discussions, making her leadership style both revolutionary and contentious.
As the Church in Wales continues to evolve under Vann’s oversight, the church faces scrutiny both domestically and within the global Anglican community. Vann acknowledged the challenges, stating, “There are still people in our church who struggle with women in leadership, let alone someone in a same-sex relationship.” This recognition of resistance within her own ranks underscores the significant work ahead.
The church’s Governing Body holds the keys to any future doctrinal changes, requiring majority votes from bishops, clergy, and laity — a tall order given existing divisions. Recent developments, such as Nigeria’s withdrawal, highlight the implications of these internal disagreements. The Church of Nigeria, a major player in the Anglican Communion with over 18 million members, signals not only institutional ramifications but also a widening divide that may shift the dynamics of Anglicanism worldwide.
Vann, however, remains focused on her duties. With her leadership, there is potential for reconciliation and growth, but whether the church can maintain its unity amidst such change is uncertain. In her own words, “It’s also about being visible.” Her presence within the church serves as a beacon for many, particularly young girls who aspire to leadership roles. Yet, the path forward is fraught with tensions that are not likely to dissipate any time soon.
As Vann leads the Church in Wales, she confronts both opportunity and challenge. The future of the church will hinge on its ability to navigate these waters, balancing tradition with a modernizing ethos while maintaining coherence amidst differing beliefs within the Anglican family. The question looms: Can Vann’s leadership bridge the divides, or will it deepen them further?
"*" indicates required fields
