Bishop Joseph Strickland recently made headlines during the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) Spring Plenary Assembly with a pointed concern regarding the confirmation of ABC News anchor Gio Benitez, a married man in a same-sex relationship. Strickland’s comments reveal critical tensions within the Church and the struggle to uphold longstanding doctrine amid shifting societal norms.
The bishop openly questioned the appropriateness of publicly celebrating Benitez’s confirmation when his marital status is well known. “I don’t know how many of us have seen on social media,” Strickland said, demanding clarity from his fellow bishops. The assembly took place in Louisville, Kentucky, and Strickland’s remarks highlighted a clash between Church teachings and contemporary acceptance of same-sex marriage.
Images circulated on social media depicted clergy joyously celebrating Benitez’s confirmation, raising alarms for those who hold traditional views on marriage, which the Catechism of the Catholic Church defines as a union specifically between a man and a woman. Strickland noted the confusion this celebration could potentially cause among the faithful. He stated, “Celebrating something that is clearly contrary to what the Church teaches sends a very confusing message.”
Despite the gravity of his comments, the leadership of the USCCB moved forward without addressing Strickland’s concerns. Most Reverend James Massa, auxiliary bishop of Brooklyn, seamlessly transitioned the discussion toward different topics, notably a forthcoming “faith and science” symposium. This swift redirection has not gone unnoticed, sparking frustration among some observers and clergy members who felt Strickland’s appeals deserved more attention.
The incident reflects wider fractures within the American Church, as bishops grapple with how to navigate the bright line between doctrinal integrity and the push for inclusion. While many American Catholics have shifted toward more progressive views—61% supporting same-sex marriage according to a 2023 Pew Research survey—the hierarchy remains divided. Some bishops focus on outreach, while others insist on adherence to the Church’s teachings without compromise.
Bishop Strickland’s position underscores a growing concern that a disconnect exists between established doctrine and the practical implications of pastoral actions. Public figures contradicting Church teachings can undermine moral coherence within the faith community. As Strickland emphasized, the role of bishops extends beyond mere acknowledgment of these issues; they hold the responsibility to offer guidance and clarity to the faithful.
A diocesan priest succinctly encapsulated the dilemma faced by Church leadership when he said, “When silence replaces shepherding, sheep go astray.” This remark illustrates the imperative for bishops to confront uncomfortable realities in service of their flock.
The USCCB has yet to issue official commentary on Benitez’s confirmation or Strickland’s critique, leaving many supporters and churchgoers wondering how such cases are assessed across different locales. Canon law allows for considerable latitude regarding the administration of the sacraments, yet the application of key principles regarding those “obstinately persevering in manifest grave sin” remains a contentious debate within the body of bishops.
As discussions pivoted quickly away from Strickland’s concerns, there was a palpable message about how leadership grapples with the complexities of modern society and traditional beliefs. It raises essential questions regarding the future direction of the Church: Is the urgency to avoid conflict overshadowing the duty to uphold doctrinal truths?
Bishop Strickland remains steadfast in his commitment to articulating doctrine as a primary concern. “I didn’t speak out to attack anyone,” he asserted. “But if we are not willing to stand up for what we believe, we risk becoming no different than the world around us.” His remarks resonate deeply in the current context, where the Church finds itself at a crossroads. Balancing tradition and contemporary realities will continue to challenge the faith community. With leaders like Strickland advocating for clarity and adherence to longstanding teachings, the path forward will likely remain complex and debated among clergy and laity alike.
"*" indicates required fields
