Florida Governor Ron DeSantis has launched a vigorous critique of New York City’s newly elected Mayor Zohran Mamdani, labeling him a “Marxist” and an “Islamist.” This rhetoric marks DeSantis’s attempt to frame Florida as a beacon of resistance against what he perceives as a dangerous leftward shift in blue states, particularly New York.
Speaking at various events in Miami, DeSantis said, “He is a Marxist. He is also an Islamist,” a sentiment that resonated widely on social media. His comments came during a series of activities commemorating Victims of Communism Day, emphasizing the ongoing political discourse surrounding Mamdani’s unexpected election win. During a session with over 250 high school students at the Freedom Tower—an emblem of Cuban refugee history—DeSantis highlighted Florida’s commitment to education on the perils of communism. This location holds historical significance, serving as a former processing center for Cubans fleeing Fidel Castro’s regime, and has helped shape the state’s anti-communist narratives.
“I can’t think of a place in this country that has a more instinctive understanding of the dangers of communism than we have in our South Florida communities,” he asserted, underscoring the connection between local history and current ideological battles. The governor announced new educational programs aimed at expanding lessons on 20th-century communist regimes, asserting that today’s youth must grasp the gravity of socialism’s failures, from the Russian Revolution onward through Cuba and Venezuela. “Only people who have never studied a lick of history would think that could work,” DeSantis argued, referring to Mamdani’s platform.
Mamdani, who identifies as a democratic socialist, has proposed policies like extending rent control and creating government-run grocery stores. These plans, linked to failed socialist economies by DeSantis and other conservatives, have become a rallying point for criticism. The backlash intensified, with figures like Sean Hannity of Fox News pointing to polling that suggests many New Yorkers are considering leaving the city if Mamdani implements his agenda. “Florida will get an influx,” DeSantis stated confidently.
The concept of residents fleeing New York for Florida plays into DeSantis’s larger narrative. Census data indicates that New York lost over 180,000 residents between mid-2021 and mid-2022, while Florida gained a net increase of more than 300,000. Florida’s appeal lies in its contrasting landscape of lower taxes and perceived safety compared to New York’s rising crime rates and regulatory heaviness. DeSantis pointed out a significant voter shift in Florida, boasting an increase of 1.4 million more registered Republicans since he took office. This demographic change particularly resonates in a state with many residents having ancestry from countries that endured socialist regimes, like Cuba.
Amid this backdrop, Rep. Carlos Giménez, a Cuban-born Republican, reinforced DeSantis’s assessment: “I know a communist and a Marxist when I see one… Mamdani in New York, he’s a Marxist.” Mamdani, however, has pushed back against this classification, stating in an NBC News interview, “I am not,” directly denying the communist label imposed on him.
The critiques of Mamdani have focused not only on his policies but also on his previous statements regarding police reform, which have drawn sharp criticism from law enforcement supporters. DeSantis highlighted concerns about public safety, stating that Mamdani’s comments about the NYPD being “haram” resonate poorly with police officers. This remark, though taken out of context, has fueled apprehension among supporters of law enforcement. “I think people are going to run for the hills,” DeSantis warned, implying that police officers may feel unsupported under Mamdani’s leadership.
Furthermore, some media outlets have pointed out Mamdani’s lack of acknowledgment of the NYPD’s role in responding to the 9/11 attacks. Republican Rep. Andy Ogles recently shared a video of the Twin Towers’ destruction, urging New Yorkers to “wake up” to their city’s perceived decline under Mamdani’s incoming administration.
On the policy front, Education Commissioner Anastasios Kamoutsas has joined efforts with DeSantis to incorporate anti-communist themes into Florida’s K-12 curriculum. He claims that modern progressive ideas like socialized retail and wealth redistribution reflect “communist ideology,” asserting the need to promote freedom-based teachings. This was emphasized when he stated, “If the ideology is freedom, I am okay to push that ideology,” reinforcing the ideological divide between Florida and states that lean left.
The timing of DeSantis’s rhetoric has not gone unnoticed, particularly as it coincides with controversial developments regarding migrant policies affecting Venezuelans. Critics have expressed concern over the lack of mention of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security’s decision to end protections for Venezuelan migrants, noting it contradicts the state’s staunch anti-socialist narrative. By ignoring current policies affecting those fleeing socialism while stressing historical victims, critics argue that DeSantis is prioritizing political advantage over humanitarian consistency.
Despite the controversy, some Venezuelan leaders, like opposition figure María Corina Machado, have praised Florida’s stance against socialist regimes. “If there is one community I need to thank, it is the Venezuelan diaspora in Florida,” she remarked, emphasizing the community’s role in raising awareness about socialism’s impact.
Meanwhile, Miami Mayor Francis Suarez predicted that real estate prices could surge by “up to 40%” due to migration from states like New York, stating, “People are voting with their feet.”
As Mamdani prepares to assume office, Florida leaders continue to escalate their messaging, framing their state as a stronghold of conservative values in stark opposition to the progressive policies anticipated from New York’s new leadership. Whether the warnings about Mamdani’s policies ultimately resonate with voters or draw more residents to Florida is yet to unfold. For DeSantis and the Florida Republican Party, however, this discourse regarding values and governance is more than mere debate; it is a strategic battleground.
"*" indicates required fields
