A recent discussion on social media has spotlighted the ongoing debate within the Republican Party regarding immigration enforcement during President Donald Trump’s second term. Political commentator Jennings challenged a claim from a leftist who asserted that several two-time Trump voters expressed regret over his immigration policies. Jennings insisted, “I dispute it!” This exchange hints at deeper divisions within the party than the tweet suggests.
The UC Berkeley Institute of Governmental Studies has released data indicating significant discomfort among Republican voters about Trump’s enforcement tactics. While the majority of Democrats oppose these measures—between 88% and 95%—the numbers reveal that many Republicans are not fully aligned with the party’s hardline stance. A notable 20% of Republican respondents oppose key aspects of Trump’s immigration crackdown. This is particularly pronounced in California, where 5,000 registered voters were surveyed.
Intra-Party Divide on Immigration
The survey results expose a rift within the Republican electorate. Support for requiring ICE agents to present identification during enforcement actions is favored by 45% of Republicans. Moreover, 58% of moderate Republican women oppose expanding ICE operations to sensitive areas like schools and hospitals. Researchers observe that “young Republicans break on approximately four issues compared to older Republicans who break on two or three.” Intriguingly, Latino Republicans diverge from party norms on immigration more frequently than their Asian and White counterparts, demonstrating that the Republican base does not uniformly embrace hardline enforcement strategies.
On-the-Ground Impact on Immigrants
The KFF and The New York Times conducted a nationwide survey that unveils the troubling reality faced by many immigrants. As of June 2025, 22% reported knowing someone who had been detained or deported since January 2021. This indicates a stark increase from just 8% two years prior, with most of the detained individuals lacking serious criminal records. Rising fear among the immigrant community is evident, with 41% of all immigrants worried about deportation, escalating from 26% in 2023. The concern is even higher among likely undocumented immigrants, at 75%.
Personal testimonies reflect this anxiety: a Korean immigrant woman noted, “Now we must carry our passports on our bodies when we step out.” A young Japanese immigrant shared, “Friends and family… are getting deported without due process.” Such sentiments highlight the serious implications of current immigration policies on individuals’ daily lives.
Behavioral and Economic Fallout
The KFF/New York Times survey suggests that this pervasive climate of fear is prompting immigrants to alter their behaviors. About 30% of immigrants now avoid various public activities, including school events and work, while the number jumps to 74% among undocumented immigrants. Economically, half of immigrant households report struggling to meet essential expenses, up from 31% in 2023. Nearly half stated that earning a living has become harder since Trump resumed office. These challenges extend beyond undocumented individuals and increasingly affect those with legal status as well.
Despite this widespread anxiety, public support for President Trump’s handling of immigration has dwindled. Approval now sits at a mere 41%, one of the lowest since he returned to office. Polls by Reuters/Ipsos and Harvard CAPS/Harris during mid-2025 show that aggressive deportation measures like workplace raids are meeting disapproval across party lines, including among Republicans, as support for such tactics begins to fade.
Changing Attitudes on Immigration
Gallup polling illustrates a significant shift in attitudes toward immigration. Support for reducing immigration levels among Republicans dropped from 88% to 48% between 2024 and mid-2025. Conversely, favorable views of immigration among Republicans rose from 39% to 64%. Overall, positive feelings about immigration now sit at 79% among all Americans.
Lydia Saad, director of U.S. Social Research at Gallup, noted that “the Trump administration’s swift and visible response appears to have defused concerns about border chaos.” However, these methods are inciting backlash. Immigration experts warn that such harsh tactics may ultimately undermine the administration’s position. Stephen Yale-Loehr, a former Cornell law professor, remarked, “Deportation efforts are backfiring.” Additionally, David Bier from the Cato Institute emphasized, “The poll shows clearly that the public is reacting negatively to President Trump’s immigration agenda.”
White House Defends Policy
Despite the declining approval ratings, the administration remains steadfast in its policies. White House spokeswoman Abigail Jackson asserted, “Americans have a lot less to be worried about… He is fulfilling the promises he was elected on.” The enforcement statistics support these claims, with ICE arresting over 100,000 individuals from January to June 2025, boasting of “zero illegal aliens released” during two consecutive months.
This messaging aligns with Jennings’ tweet, implying that Trump voters knew what they wanted when they elected him. However, polling data indicates that even Trump’s base is growing uneasy about the realities of strict immigration enforcement, particularly concerning methods that target non-criminal immigrants and sensitive locations.
Bottom Line
While overall public support for stringent border security remains robust—with over 60% in favor of deporting immigrants with criminal records—the acceptance of broader enforcement measures is beginning to slip. Within the GOP, particularly in states like California, younger voters, Latinos, and moderate women are distancing themselves from the party’s established messaging. As the next presidential election approaches, these shifting perspectives could significantly influence immigration policy and the Republican Party’s cohesion. Voters may not be surprised by Trump enforcing immigration laws, but many are increasingly concerned about the enforcement methods being implemented.
"*" indicates required fields
