Christianity Today has made a notable appointment with the selection of Reverend Doctor Nicole Massie Martin as its new president and CEO. This decision, announced on November 19, further cements the publication’s shift toward more progressive stances that some critics see as contrary to traditional evangelical values.
Martin steps into her new role with extensive credentials. Her resume includes 25 years of experience in nonprofit and ministry leadership, along with advanced degrees from respected institutions. She previously served as the Chief Impact Officer and chief operating officer at Christianity Today. This depth of experience garnered the unanimous support of the search committee, culminating in the board’s affirmation of her leadership.
Despite her impressive background, conservative voices are expressing worry over what her leadership might herald for the magazine’s future. Colin Redemer, from American Reformer, is particularly critical of Martin’s past at the American Bible Society. He notes that her work there, particularly with the “Trauma Healing Institute,” indicated a significant shift away from the organization’s core mission of promoting biblical literacy. Redemer’s comments underscore a fear that Martin’s presidency could further align Christianity Today with what he describes as a “woke trajectory.”
Concerns are not only rooted in organizational direction but also in how Martin has publicly shared her personal experiences. In a 2023 article, she opened up about a distressing incident involving a traffic stop by a police officer, which she said triggered panic and fear in her. Her narrative included reflections on broader issues of race and police violence, mentioning high-profile cases that have sparked national conversations. “Images of Black men and women shot for minor offenses raced through my mind,” she wrote, illustrating a personal connection to societal issues that resonate deeply in today’s cultural climate.
Martin’s vision for her new role includes aspirations to unify the church “beyond ideological and political boundaries.” However, her emphasis on personal experiences tied to contemporary social issues raises questions about the potential for continued ideological division within the evangelical community. Critics worry that her focus on trauma and societal narratives may detract from the core biblical mission of evangelism.
The backdrop of Martin’s hiring suggests an ongoing debate about the future of evangelical publications and their relationship with traditional values. As many conservative leaders evaluate the implications of her presidency, the conversation is not just about one individual but the broader trajectory of Christianity Today itself. The decisions made in this new era will likely shape how evangelicals engage with both faith and culture moving forward.
"*" indicates required fields
