As Thanksgiving approaches, a familiar sense of warmth and gratitude fills many homes across the U.S. However, an undercurrent of controversy surrounds this cherished holiday as some educators and institutions challenge its traditional narrative. The focus on diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) is shaping how Thanksgiving is taught in classrooms, sparking significant debate about its colonial roots.
At the University of California, Davis, the California History-Social Science Project hosted a Zoom event titled “Decolonizing Thanksgiving in the Classroom.” The aim was clear: to “reframe classroom practices” and incorporate perspectives from Turtle Island, a term some Indigenous people use to refer to North America. The event encourages educators to rethink how they approach Thanksgiving, pushing for a deeper understanding of the holiday’s complexities. This idea of “decolonizing” a widely celebrated holiday has been met with mixed reactions. The initiative promotes discussions intended to shape new meanings for students, urging educators to acknowledge the historical narratives that have often been overlooked.
Washington University in St. Louis recently echoed this sentiment, promoting an event to “highlight and honor” varying cultural perspectives on Thanksgiving. The press release underscored an effort to blend historical awareness with modern traditions, aiming to contribute to what they describe as inclusive and equitable practices. This approach emphasizes the need for systemic change, merging education with cultural sensitivity.
Further illustrating this trend, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) announced its “4th annual Thanksgiving Myth-busting” event, which explores narratives around colonialism while featuring screenings of “Buffy the Vampire Slayer.” Students are encouraged to attend the National Indigenous Day of Mourning rally in Plymouth, Massachusetts, coinciding with Thanksgiving. The MIT spokesperson acknowledged the school’s closure for the holiday but emphasized students’ freedom to express their views regarding it. They stated, “The views expressed by an individual are their own and do not reflect those of MIT or the wider community.”
The University of Massachusetts has taken a more defined stance by referring to Thanksgiving as a “Day of Mourning” on its Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Accessibility website. This change aims to educate the public about the struggles faced by Native Americans. Their announcement points to the historical significance of the day, aiming to dispel myths surrounding the Thanksgiving story while raising awareness about ongoing challenges for Indigenous tribes.
In New Mexico, Albuquerque Public Schools echoed similar thoughts in their November Indigenous Education update, explaining how many Native people do not celebrate Thanksgiving due to its connection to “the genocide of millions” and the appropriation of Native lands. The Berkeley Unified School District also addressed the complex legacy of the holiday, encouraging contemplation of the “painful legacy” and “nuanced perspectives” of Thanksgiving.
Amid these discussions, voices advocating for a return to the holiday’s unifying spirit have emerged. Paul Runko, senior director of Strategic Initiatives at Defending Education, articulated the sentiment against divisive teachings. He stated, “Thanksgiving is meant to bring people together, not to divide students or cast blame over heritage.” Runko emphasized the holiday’s potential for fostering community and gratitude, reminding us that President George Washington once called for a day to give thanks for the nation’s blessings.
In conclusion, the emerging dialogues around Thanksgiving highlight a significant shift in educational approaches to history and tradition. As institutions seek to incorporate diverse perspectives, the holiday’s essence is being both celebrated and scrutinized. The challenge lies in balancing historical truths with the spirit of a holiday meant to promote unity and reflection.
"*" indicates required fields
