Vice President JD Vance’s pre-Thanksgiving address at Fort Campbell, Kentucky, has stirred reactions by challenging the beloved American tradition of Thanksgiving turkey. His blunt remarks—”Who REALLY likes turkey?”—showcase a raw humor aimed at engaging troops, but also highlight a growing ambivalence toward longstanding customs.
Vance’s skepticism about turkey’s taste marks a striking departure from the usual reverence for holiday rituals. He stated, “Whilst Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday, I think turkey doesn’t actually taste that good.” This honesty resonates with many who feel shackled to tradition rather than relishing it. The Vice President went on to poke fun at the necessity of deep-frying the bird to enhance its flavor, raising an eyebrow at how often people find themselves roasting a heavy turkey for the occasion. His conclusion that if frying is necessary to enjoy it, “maybe it’s not worth eating” provokes thought about what Thanksgiving should mean.
However, humor can have consequences. Vance’s wisecracks, deemed by some as off-color, overshadowed the core of his visit—honoring the service members. Many Americans prepare turkey out of obligation, with a 2022 Harris Poll revealing that 29% would prefer alternatives. Vance’s mockery reflected this cultural sentiment but also risked alienating soldiers who expect honor and camaraderie before a holiday focused on gratitude.
His comments sparked conversations about safety too. The hazards of deep-frying turkey are serious, with the National Fire Protection Association attributing numerous injuries and millions in property damage to these cooking practices every Thanksgiving. Fire safety risks are well-documented, yet the allure of flavor keeps deep-fried turkey a popular choice. Vance’s openness to the method might trivialize these warnings for some. Lorraine Carli from the NFPA aptly stated, “Keeping a close eye on what’s cooking… can help ensure a festive, fire-free holiday.”
Vance’s delivery mirrors a broader cultural discontent with ritualized traditions. Thanksgiving, with its parades and pumpkin pie, often goes without scrutiny. The Vice President’s challenge to turkey night speaks to those weary of obligatory feasts. It’s a sentiment that resonates in a society increasingly questioning the status quo.
Yet as significant as culinary preferences are, safety cannot be overlooked. Observers worry that downplaying the risks associated with frying could embolden careless behavior, particularly among those unacquainted with proper cooking safety. In 2020, states like Arkansas and Texas faced multiple fryer-related incidents during Thanksgiving week, a reminder of the dangers mingling with festive cheer.
In contrast, the holiday remains a stage for evolving tastes. Surveys indicate a shift in perspective, with a Butterball poll showing 85% of Americans feeling pressured to serve turkey even if they dislike it. Alternatives like ham or plant-based dishes are increasingly favored. Vance’s candid approach contributes to this discussion, pushing past polite nods to tradition.
Ultimately, Vance’s address encapsulated an honesty that many may appreciate. His straightforward tone suits the informal gathering of troops, prioritizing humor and a touch of irreverence. Yet, it blurs the line between jest and recklessness, calling into question what Thanksgiving symbolizes today. While traditions carry weight, taste and safety must also hold a place in the conversation. In the end, cooking—or not cooking—turkey reveals deeper insights about how Americans relate to their cherished holidays.
"*" indicates required fields
