Brown University President Christina Paxson is facing severe criticism following the tragic shooting deaths of two students on campus last weekend. The incident left the community reeling and highlights major security failures at an institution with an enormous $8 billion endowment. It took five days for law enforcement to apprehend the alleged shooter, who ultimately took his own life. This delay raises serious questions about the university’s security measures, particularly the notable absence of security cameras in the area where the students lost their lives.
During a press conference, a reporter confronted Paxson directly about the absence of surveillance in the building. “You didn’t have cameras in that building. Just say it, so we can get this over with,” the reporter pressed, making clear the weight of the failure on the university’s shoulders. The president, however, deflected responsibility, stating that the lack of cameras did not contribute to the tragedy.
This incident spotlights not only the inadequate video security but also a broader issue with campus safety. Some assert that Brown’s lax security policy mirrors the open borders rhetoric permeating current political discourse. During an intense exchange, it was suggested that security cameras were omitted for reasons including sanctuary laws meant to protect undocumented immigrants. This idea presents a troubling parallel between the university’s policies and national border security practices, which critics accuse of compromising safety for the sake of political correctness.
Providence’s Mayor Brett Smiley underscored the flaws in campus security, stating simply, “There’s no wall and no gates.” This means Brown’s campus remains vulnerable and accessible to anyone—inclusive of potentially dangerous individuals—despite the exorbitant tuition fees that students pay. The cost approaches $100,000 annually, raising the stakes for students and their families, who expect a safe environment and valuable return on their investment in education.
Student feedback reinforces these concerns. Clarissa Thorne-Disla, a junior, noted the permissive access, stating, “The campus is extremely open.” Many buildings lack security checks, and even those that require ID are often left propped open. This lack of access control renders the campus less safe and raises questions regarding the effectiveness of the university’s commitment to student safety.
In charge of public safety at Brown is Rodney Chatman, whose hiring in 2021 was focused on addressing issues in policing, including bias. His notable absence from critical discussions about campus security draws skepticism. Critics question whether his priorities align with effectively safeguarding students, especially given the current climate of heightened vulnerability.
The ideology underpinning Brown’s security situation resonates alarmingly with broader national themes, especially the contentious stance on immigration and safety policies being advanced by some political factions. The “open campus” ethos, unchecked by robust safeguards, can resemble the contentious push towards open borders, as critics argue that widespread disregard for security puts lives at risk.
The outcry following this tragedy calls attention to the pressing need for reassessment of security protocols at academic institutions. The expectation is clear: schools, especially those with substantial resources, must prioritize student safety. The insistence on balance between inclusivity and safety cannot be understated; failing to recognize this duality risks both lives and the integrity of the educational experience.
As more details emerge, the accountability of institutional leaders like Paxson will continue to be scrutinized. For an Ivy League school known for its prestige, the repercussions of such security failures will weigh heavily on its legacy. It is imperative for educational institutions to prioritize protecting their students over the optics of political correctness. Safe learning environments must be non-negotiable, lest they echo the same vulnerabilities that plague the nation’s borders.
"*" indicates required fields
