In Germany, taxpayers are facing an alarming situation regarding the financial support allocated to asylum seekers and illegal migrants. Currently, billions of euros are funneled into welfare programs for these groups, all while working- and middle-class citizens struggle with rising living costs and deteriorating public services. The revelations come from a report by the German portal NIUS, which highlights how unaccompanied minor asylum seekers have racked up costs of at least €12.2 billion, roughly $14.2 billion, since 2015.
This figure, according to critics, is likely an underestimation. Many federal states have failed to deliver complete data, leaving taxpayers in the dark about the full extent of expenditures. Nationalist-conservative lawmakers have flagged this issue, indicating that full transparency is essential. With nearly 190,000 unaccompanied minors registered over the past decade, the financial implications are daunting. Costs for these minors are notably higher compared to adults because of their specific needs — housing, medical services, language education, and youth welfare. Reports suggest that annual costs can reach up to €100,000, or about $116,000, per minor in some regions.
As public services face cuts, spending on unaccompanied minors has raised serious concerns among citizens. “This isn’t just about numbers; it’s about priorities,” one opposition lawmaker, who chose to remain anonymous, stated. Their words resonate with many who see government resources directed towards newcomers, all while pensioners and families navigate reduced support systems.
The demographics of these minors are telling; the majority are teenage boys from countries like Afghanistan, Syria, and Iraq, making up over 85% of arrivals in specific states. The situation is further aggravated by chain migration, allowing recognized minors to bring over family members and inflating costs beyond initial estimates. Complications arising from inconsistent data reporting have created a climate of mistrust. Costs are reported after significant delays, with some regions billing up to three years late. As René Springer, an AfD lawmaker, put it, failure to provide complete figures is “nothing short of a scandal.”
Alice Weidel, co-leader of the AfD, has also voiced strong criticism regarding the staggering expenditures over the last nine years, pinpointing the lack of coherent data from CDU-led states. “The asylum chaos must end immediately to alleviate the burden on taxpayers,” she asserted, encapsulating the growing call for accountability.
The stark contrast between the government’s spending on migrants and the struggles of average citizens intensifies the situation. Families deal with soaring rents and increased living expenses while public sectors, such as schools and hospitals, are overwhelmed. Maria Schultz, a factory worker in Berlin and mother of two, expressed the sentiments shared by many: “How can the government summon endless funds for migrants but claim austerity for us?”
As the situation evolves, Germany finds itself at a pivotal moment. The pressure is mounting on leaders to address the economic realities facing their constituents or risk further alienating a populace already feeling neglected. The ongoing debate focuses not just on financial accountability but also on a deeper examination of the true costs of the nation’s approach to asylum and migration amidst a broader reckoning about governance, fairness, and the protection of working-class interests.
"*" indicates required fields
