Trump Draws Tens of Thousands in Return to Butler, Pa.—Site of July Assassination Attempt
On October 7, former President Donald Trump commanded a massive crowd in Butler, Pennsylvania. The atmosphere crackled with energy as chants of “USA! USA!” echoed. One tweet captured the scene, highlighting the pride and fervor of the attending supporters: “🚨 NOW: President Trump takes the stage to a MASSIVE crowd of patriots chanting ‘USA! USA!’ Pennsylvania loves President Trump 🇺🇸.”
This was no ordinary rally. It took place at the Butler Farm Showgrounds, the very site where Trump faced an assassination attempt on July 13, 2024. During that tragic event, 20-year-old Thomas Matthew Crooks unleashed gunfire from a nearby position. While Trump survived with a gunshot wound to his ear, Corey Comperatore, a devoted supporter, lost his life while shielding his family. Crooks was killed by Secret Service agents who responded to the threat.
During this significant rally, Trump reinforced themes of resilience and survival. “I will never quit. I will never bend. I will never break. I will never yield, not even in the face of death itself,” he declared, embodying the spirit of defiance and determination.
Beyond the emotional weight of the occasion, Trump’s return to Butler holds strategic importance. As the GOP nominee, Pennsylvania remains a critical state for his campaign. Following a victory in 2016, he lost this battleground state in 2020. Reinforcing support in regions like Butler County, historically a Republican bastion, is integral to reclaiming presidential support.
The question of crowd size loomed over the event. While Trump’s campaign boasted about attracting between 100,000 and 105,000 attendees, independent estimates paint a different picture. A Newsweek analysis suggested attendance likely ranged from 30,000 to 57,000 based on crowd density and space. Professor Steve Doig from Arizona State University noted that achieving Trump’s claimed numbers would require an unrealistic level of crowd compression, indicating the complexities of accurately assessing attendance at such events.
Despite debates over numbers, the sentiments of attendees like Steve Schwartzmiller were unequivocal. “It doesn’t matter which Democrat they put up. It’s the Democrats that got us where we are, and we need a change,” he asserted, highlighting a widespread desire for political shift among the crowd.
The memory of the July shooting cast a somber shadow over the rally. At 6:11 p.m., the moment when gunfire erupted months prior, Trump led a bell chime and called for a moment of silence. “Twelve weeks ago, we all took a bullet for America,” he remarked, honoring the sacrifices made that day, particularly Comperatore’s heroism.
This rally also served to redefine Trump’s campaign message as the general election approaches. He focused on personal strength, law enforcement, border security, and energy independence—key issues resonating with his base. Criticism of the Biden administration was prevalent, particularly regarding policies affecting Pennsylvania’s energy sector, including fracking.
Add to this the dramatic presence of billionaire Elon Musk, who endorsed Trump during the rally. Musk emphatically stated, “Democrats want to take away your right to vote… to speak… to defend yourself. President Trump must win to preserve the Constitution.” His appearance connected tech giants to a grassroots movement, amplifying the stakes of the election.
U.S. Senator J.D. Vance joined Trump on stage, addressing the incident and criticizing the White House’s response to recent storm relief in North Carolina, contrasting Trump’s focus on safety to the administration’s handling of crisis resourcing.
Security at the rally reflected the events of the past summer. Throughout the venue, Secret Service agents positioned snipers and drones, while local law enforcement maintained a visible presence. Chris Harpster, a witness at both the July attack and the rally, remarked on the heightened security, noting, “Last time, the shots hit before anyone could react. This time, you could feel the watchful eyes everywhere. It felt safe.”
The Secret Service continues to investigate the July shooting, with Acting Director Ronald Rowe confirming ongoing reviews of security measures that failed to prevent Crooks from carrying out the attack. The investigation underscores concerns about vulnerabilities and paves the way for potential security improvements at future events.
Trump’s focus on the shooting incident doesn’t overlook the other victims. David Dutch and James Copenhaver also sustained severe injuries that day. Trump has made it a point to honor their struggles in his speeches, often revisiting the traumatic experience of being shot himself. “By the hand of providence and the grace of God, we survived,” he has repeatedly stated, a theme that resonated throughout his return to Butler.
This rally comes at a pivotal moment for Trump. With the Republican National Convention on the horizon, anticipation mounts regarding his vice-presidential pick. Recently, he hinted at revealing the choice during the convention, suggesting this would amplify the political theater surrounding the event.
The rally’s location—where Trump had once been injured—serves as a potent symbol for his supporters. The historical significance of Butler County, which delivered 66% of its votes to Trump in 2020, underscores the campaign’s efforts to rally support and bolster turnout in this crucial battleground. Trump campaign adviser Chris LaCivita previously stated, “Pennsylvania, clearly, is going to be the center of the universe for the next 30 days.”
However, dissent still simmers in the surrounding community. Resident Heidi Priest expressed her unease over the July shooting, stating, “I believe we’re more divided now than ever.” Her perspective reflects a growing rift as the election draws near.
Trump’s return to Butler, marked by elements of grief, survival, and dramatic political theater, showcases his strategy of leaning heavily into powerful symbolism and emotional appeals. The efficacy of this strategy in mobilizing voters come November remains to be seen.
"*" indicates required fields
