Former President Donald Trump’s recent comments regarding American soybeans highlight a critical issue in U.S.-China trade relations. During a public address, he shared a conversation with Chinese President Xi Jinping, claiming, “I told this to President Xi – our soybeans are more nutritious than competitors!” While the remark drew laughter, it underscores the dire circumstances American soybean farmers face.
With the APEC forum approaching, Trump’s statements serve as a reminder of the ongoing struggle to regain market share lost during the trade dispute. U.S. soybean producers have experienced severe financial losses since China shifted its focus to Brazil and other suppliers. Once the largest buyer of American soybeans, China’s withdrawal has cost farmers billions.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture has documented a staggering decline in soybean purchases from China, especially during the trade war from 2018 to 2020. By January 2019, U.S. soybean sales to China fell dramatically to just 332,000 metric tons, far below the expected totals. This decline severely affected many farmers, emphasizing the importance of restoring those lost sales.
Senator John Hoeven of North Dakota emphasized the urgency of the situation during a briefing with U.S. Ambassador to China David Perdue, stating, “We need to keep the pressure on until we get sales.” He noted that China continues to buy heavily from Brazil, highlighting the competitive disadvantage American exporters face. With the stakes high, Trump’s focus on soybean sales has become a central theme ahead of the upcoming meeting with Xi.
China’s strategy has shifted, as it now sources over half of its soybeans from Brazil, resulting in a decline of U.S. market share in Chinese imports from about 34% in 2017 to below 20%. Economists express skepticism about the ease of reversing this trend, as analyst Tanner Ehmke remarked, “We are still not even close to what has been advertised.” Disappointing purchase figures led to a swift drop in soybean futures, illustrating the market’s volatility and sensitivity to trade news.
Despite this cautious outlook, there are signs of potential progress. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent announced recent commitments from China, totaling 12 million metric tons of U.S. soybeans, aiming to increase that to 25 million tons annually over the next three years. If this deal holds true, it may pave the way for a recovery in American soybean exports, yet the visibility of these transactions remains uncertain.
Even with forward movement, there’s a sense of wariness within the community. Bryan Burack from the Heritage Foundation highlighted China’s long-term strategy to reduce reliance on U.S. agriculture, noting that this trend began before Trump’s administration. This forewarning signals a potential struggle to reclaim market dominance, especially as countries like Brazil gain favorable conditions for production and shipping.
American soybean farmers are grappling with challenges beyond international competition. They are exploring alternative uses for soybeans, like renewable diesel, but these options currently make up a fraction of demand. “You can’t take our No. 1 customer, shut them off and just overnight find a replacement,” said Brad Arnold, a soybean farmer in Missouri. This sentiment echoes the frustration felt by many who depend on stable exports to China.
The disparity in costs and market access between U.S. and Brazilian soybeans complicates matters further. Brazilian soybeans are less expensive due to favorable currency rates and significant Chinese investments in South American agriculture. In this context, American soybean growers find themselves at a disadvantage, no longer the default choice for Chinese imports.
China’s perspective emphasizes cooperation and stability in its economic dealings with the U.S. A spokesperson stated, “The essence of China-U.S. economic and trade cooperation is mutual benefit and win-win.” Yet, this hopeful outlook contrasts sharply with the reality faced by American farmers who are anxious for more than just diplomatic assurances.
The forthcoming meeting in South Korea between Trump and Xi stands as a pivotal moment for U.S. agriculture. Farmers who placed their faith in Trump during previous elections are expecting concrete actions rather than mere words. The potential for negotiation is there, but so too are long-term trends that have altered the landscape of global soybean supply chains.
As for Trump’s humorous remarks about soybean nutrition, they serve as a backdrop to a serious economic challenge. The fight over trade and America’s agricultural future continues, and it is clear that the resolution is far from settled. Whether humor can translate into meaningful change remains to be seen in the unfolding saga of U.S.-China relations.
"*" indicates required fields
