Celebrities are often quick to voice their opinions, but the current flood of commentary surrounding the crisis in Minneapolis feels more like noise than meaningful discourse. It calls to mind the deafening silence many of these stars maintained during the Harvey Weinstein scandal—a convenient quietude that allowed them to pursue their careers unchallenged. Now, they seem eager to weigh in on political issues yet conveniently avoid addressing graver global concerns, like the plight of Iranian women facing persecution.
Among the bold names joining the fray are Billie Eilish, Pedro Pascal, Olivia Wilde, and Ellen DeGeneres, who, despite contributing to an already crowded conversation about Immigration and Customs Enforcement, have failed to bring any fresh insight. The conversation has entered a zone where celebrity remarks are more of an afterthought than a catalyst for change.
Jenna Ortega, while attending the Sundance Film Festival, delivered an impassioned speech. “I’m really encouraged by the spirit of the American people,” she stated, lamenting the lack of real action against the perpetrators of violence. Yet, attending a glitzy festival while speaking on somber topics undercuts the sincerity of her message. One can’t help but wonder about her commitment to the cause when she chooses fashion over action.
Olivia Wilde, draped in luxury at the same event, also spoke out against ICE, poignantly noting, “People are being murdered,” yet she adorned her assertion with an “ICE Out” pin. Symbolic gestures in the form of fashion accessories don’t equate to activism when Hollywood itself profits from glorifying violence in countless films. This irony begs the question: is it activism or mere publicity?
Celebrities like Olivia Rodrigo and Katy Perry have echoed calls against ICE, but the vague nature of their statements raises skepticism. Rodrigo declared, “Our actions matter,” yet left her followers without a clear sense of what those actions might be. Meanwhile, Perry urged her audience to contact their senators concerning ICE’s funding, but this call to action lacks tangible substance in a world critical of such vague directives.
Even Pedro Pascal, known for his passionate appeals, made light of the situation with a pun about the tragedies faced by two victims, saying they provided a “Pretti good reason” for a national strike. Humor may have its place, but in light of grievous events, it seems misaligned with the gravity of the circumstances.
And then there’s DeGeneres, a figure working hard to regain relevance after her exit from the Hollywood scene. She took to social media from afar, reminiscing about past visits to Minneapolis while expressing pride in peaceful protesters. But a statement like “I am sorry for anyone who has been hurt” feels hollow when stated from a distance, disconnected from real engagement or sacrifice.
In a world rife with serious issues, the selective outrage of these stars raises questions about authenticity and commitment. While their platforms carry a potential for influence, too often, it appears these voices prefer the comfort of celebrity over the weight of social responsibility.
"*" indicates required fields
