Democratic Senator John Fetterman’s relationship with the Working Families Party has taken a sharp turn, with the left-wing organization initiating efforts to unseat him almost three years ahead of his 2028 reelection bid. This surprising move highlights a fracture within Democratic circles, particularly among those who once championed Fetterman in his 2022 election.
The Working Families Party has launched a dedicated website, PrimaryFetterman.com, urging voters to abandon Fetterman in favor of a challenger. The site is packed with opposition research on Fetterman, links for volunteers, and even options for campaign donation refunds. The group states on its site, “We supported John Fetterman in 2022. Since then, he’s sold us out. It’s time to replace him.” This statement reflects serious discontent among the party’s members, especially regarding Fetterman’s record since taking office.
Critics within the party highlight several votes that have turned the tide against Fetterman. He has been criticized for backing a Republican budget bill, a decision that may impact healthcare costs for 500,000 Pennsylvanians. Moreover, he reportedly supported more of Donald Trump’s nominees than any other Democratic senator, leading to frustrations among those who expected Fetterman to champion progressive values. The Working Families Party has responded, asserting that “we deserve better” than a senator who skips votes and Senate responsibilities.
This discontent appears to have galvanized people within the party. Since the initiative started in November, reports indicate a surge in interest from potential challengers ready to take Fetterman on. Volunteers and donors are rallying around the idea of finding new leadership, indicating that Fetterman may be in for a serious challenge as he faces potential primary contenders who are more aligned with the party’s leftist principles.
Fetterman himself has not shied away from commenting on the situation. He appeared unconcerned when interviewed about the party’s attempts to unseat him. He sarcastically remarked, “Ooh, ooh, oh, I hope, promise. I hope so… because I guarantee whoever they put up, they’re going to make me look the reasonable guy.” His comments suggest a confidence in his ability to appeal to a broader base, despite the simmering dissatisfaction from some factions of the party.
However, Fetterman’s track record over the past year raises questions about that confidence. He has frequently broken with Democratic leadership, becoming the first sitting Democrat to engage with Donald Trump at Mar-a-Lago. Such actions have drawn ire from his party colleagues and complicated his standing among progressive voters looking for steadfastness on core issues. His staunch defense of Israel amid the Gaza war and criticism of party leadership are recent examples of his departure from party norms.
Fetterman has even entertained contentious policy ideas, like supporting the United States purchasing Greenland, a notion long associated with Trump. This has led to criticism not only from political opponents but also from insiders who feel his focus is misaligned with the needs of his constituents. Nick Gavio, a member of the Working Families Party and former Fetterman staffer, articulated this sentiment when he emphasized the disconnect between the senator’s actions and the interests of the people who supported him.
The rift between Fetterman and the Working Families Party underscores a growing tension within the Democratic Party, as factions begin to voice dissent against established figures. With the 2028 Senate election looming, Fetterman faces not just a challenge from a potential primary opponent… he is contending with a broader ideological shift that may reshape the Democratic landscape in Pennsylvania. As the party searches for new leadership that aligns more closely with progressive values, it remains to be seen how Fetterman will navigate the complexities of his evolving political environment.
"*" indicates required fields
