New York Governor Kathy Hochul is making a notable shift in her policy approach by embracing a major tenet of former President Donald Trump’s economic strategy. In a recent announcement, Hochul declared her proposal to eliminate state income tax on tips, marking a significant move aimed at easing the financial burden on service industry workers. “I’m kicking the new year off with a proposal of no state income tax on tips, continuing my efforts to make New York more affordable for hard-working New Yorkers,” she stated in a news release. This action follows her previous initiatives where she reduced income taxes for middle-class residents and enhanced child tax credits.
The proposal, set for the 2027 fiscal year, aligns New York with federal tax policy, echoing moves that Trump championed during his presidency. Under this new plan, tips received up to $25,000 will not be subject to state income taxes. The New York Post highlighted criticism from Republican officials who have pointed out that states like New York, Illinois, and California lag behind in abolishing such taxes, thereby putting unnecessary strain on their constituents.
Bruce Blakeman, Nassau County Executive and Hochul’s Republican opponent, seized on this policy reversal as a talking point. He remarked, “I see Kathy Hochul is doing a U-turn on taxing tips,” suggesting her decision was influenced by pressure from the opposition. Blakeman emphasized his own blue-collar background, stating, “I know money is earned,” and positioned himself as a fighter for working-class interests.
The broader implications of Hochul’s proposal extend beyond mere tax policy; it resonates deeply with voters who feel the weight of New York’s high taxes. Service workers have expressed discontent with Hochul’s previous inaction on this issue. Zoe Kalodimos, a waitress from Bethpage, Long Island, articulated this frustration, saying, “It’s disgraceful. People live off of tips.” She described losing significant income due to tax deductions, pointing out the struggle to maintain her livelihood in an expensive environment.
Hochul’s alignment with the “no tax on tips” initiative comes at a critical juncture, well ahead of her re-election campaign. The timing reflects her need to connect with the state’s working-class voters, especially after numerous restaurant employees voiced their disapproval towards her lack of action earlier. Such sentiments could influence her standing among constituents as the election approaches.
Moreover, her recent stance on taxation raises questions about her overall commitment to fiscal conservatism. Despite previously asserting she would not increase taxes on residents to foster affordability, discussions following the election of new New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani revealed inconsistencies in this rhetoric. Hochul and her advisors are now considering strategies to fund ambitious city projects, which may include raising taxes on wealthier New Yorkers.
New York stands out nationally with a high tax rate of 10.9 percent for its upper-income earners, in addition to a 5.5 percent rate for middle-class individuals. In contrast, states like Florida, Texas, Tennessee, and New Hampshire have no state income tax whatsoever, further complicating New York’s position in drawing and retaining residents.
As Hochul pushes forward with her proposal to eliminate the state income tax on tips, her actions will be scrutinized not just for their fiscal impact, but for how effectively she can navigate the political landscape leading up to the election. This move appears to be more than just a policy adjustment; it is a strategic necessity to align with her constituents’ interests and quell mounting discontent among those who feel neglected by their elected officials.
"*" indicates required fields
