Tensions between Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and sanctuary city governments continue to grow, particularly in Minneapolis. The agency, along with its federal allies, is intensifying efforts to address chaos and fraud, provoking ire from mayors who govern these sanctuary areas. Notably, Chicago’s Mayor Brandon Johnson has publicly criticized ICE and Border Patrol, particularly their local lead, Commander Gregory Bovino, attributing this summer’s crime issues in Chicago to their presence.
Despite a report indicating that the summer of 2025 was Chicago’s safest in decades—with “only” 123 murders recorded—crime remains an issue. Chicago’s University Crime Lab has pointed out persistent levels of violent crime, placing Chicago’s situation alongside major cities worldwide. Johnson seized upon DHS’s “Operation Midway Blitz,” launched in early September, to claim the uptick in crime was directly correlated with ICE’s ongoing activities. He declared, “Chicago had the safest summer since 1965 before Bovino stepped foot in our city. Where ICE was most active, crime went up.”
In response, DHS Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin did not hold back. She asserted that Mayor Johnson’s rhetoric exacerbates the already dangerous situation for law enforcement. McLaughlin highlighted the staggering increase in assaults against ICE officers—up a staggering 1,300%—while contrasting the challenges faced by those in Chicago with the experience of law enforcement in supportive jurisdictions like Florida. She insisted that sanctuary city policies contribute to a culture of violence, stating, “He should turn down the rhetoric and work with DHS to prevent more innocent American deaths at the hands of gang members, murderers, drug traffickers, and others who have no right to be in this country.”
Further complicating matters, CNN analyst David Axelrod attempted to bolster Mayor Johnson’s arguments, criticizing DHS’s credibility. He cited a federal judge’s remarks highlighting the pattern of misrepresentation by DHS: “It becomes difficult, if not impossible, to believe almost anything they represent as fact.” Axelrod’s comments suggest a growing distrust towards the agency, particularly in the political landscape.
Commander Bovino countered Axelrod’s assertions with pointed remarks, emphasizing that the statistics in Chicago—specifically the double-digit decreases in violent crime—reflect a different narrative. His statement underscores a stark reality in the ongoing debate: “Taking violent illegal aliens off the streets by the thousands seems to bother those who choose illegal aliens over American citizens.”
This back-and-forth between city officials and federal authorities illustrates the ongoing struggle between sanctuary policies and law enforcement’s efforts to maintain public safety. The increasing animosity between mayors like Johnson and DHS officials underscores a broader national conflict, where differing priorities on immigration and crime continuously clash. As the rhetoric escalates, the consequences for local communities become ever more apparent.
"*" indicates required fields
