In a recent address, former President Donald Trump made headlines by asserting that Democrats have shifted away from focusing on “affordability.” This statement comes in light of economic trends that Trump claims are validating his previous policies. He noted a decline in inflation rates, an increase in tax refunds, and overall improved economic conditions. “You don’t hear affordability anymore from Democrats, they’re going into other things!” he exclaimed. This emphasizes Trump’s belief that the economic landscape is transforming under his influence.
However, the economic data present a more complex picture than Trump’s assertions might suggest. Trump delivered his remarks during a campaign-style rally in Mount Pocono, Pennsylvania. While he contends that Democrats are moving away from economic issues, expert opinions and statistics indicate deeper layers of nuance in the situation.
Mixed Economic Signals
Several economic indicators show improvement, but they do not provide a full blanket of optimism. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that inflation slowed to 3% for the year ending September, down from a concerning 9.1% in June 2022. Moreover, mortgage rates have decreased from the heights of over 7.25% in the fall of 2023 to about 6.5%. Additionally, early 2024 federal tax refunds are approximately 7% higher than the previous year’s figures, encouraged by new indexing and expanded credits. Alongside these developments, forecasts for GDP growth in Q1 2024 could range between 2.6% and 3.2%, offering some reaffirmation of Trump’s claims regarding economic momentum.
Nevertheless, many challenges remain. For instance, grocery prices have continued to rise, with the food-at-home index climbing 2.7% over the last year. Furthermore, electricity costs increased by 5% during the same timeframe. Although gas prices have diminished from recent summer highs, volatility persists, and the long-term effects of inflation weigh heavily on family finances.
University of Michigan economist Betsey Stevenson criticized Trump’s economic rhetoric, saying, “Trump’s claims about inflation are false…you can go to the grocery store and see it yourself.” She emphasized that people cannot be told prices are down when they are experiencing the opposite daily in their households.
Reality Check on Political Messaging
Political consultant Frank Luntz provided insight into the potential gap between data and perception. He remarked that as the situation evolves, voter sentiment often takes longer to adjust. “When you talk about affordability, it is all perception,” Luntz explained. “The greatest danger is if you tell people happy days are here again, and it’s 1929.”
Trump’s focus on affordability has not emerged in isolation. In late 2023, as Republican support on economic matters wavered, he intensified rhetoric that suggested Democrats manipulated inflation statistics for political gain. In Mount Pocono, he reiterated this belief, dismissing concerns over affordability as a “hoax.”
Public sentiment, however, paints a cautious view. A Harvard CAPS/Harris poll from October 2023 showed that 57% of Americans felt Trump was “losing the battle against inflation,” while 68% rated the economy as “poor.” An accompanying AP-NORC survey indicated that most Americans continued to grapple with rising costs despite the improving macroeconomic indicators.
This disconnect between improving statistics and citizens’ experiences presents a significant hurdle for both political parties. Throughout the 2023 election cycle, Democrats successfully capitalized on cost-of-living issues, highlighting concerns over housing, education, and healthcare affordability. Victories in Virginia and New Jersey demonstrated the effectiveness of such messaging.
Affordability Continues to Matter
Trump’s claim that Democrats are forsaking affordability issues seems unfounded. Senate Democrats have recently proposed legislation aimed at tackling high housing costs and lowering prescription drug prices for seniors—issues expected to dominate campaign discussions through 2024 and 2026. Democratic gubernatorial candidates continue to prioritize affordability talking points, particularly in urban and suburban areas.
On the Republican front, Trump has floated various initiatives targeting housing and healthcare affordability. For example, he has suggested blocking private equity from buying homes in bulk and restructuring Obamacare subsidies. A Republican source told the Washington Examiner that even ideas typically associated with Democrats are now tools Trump might utilize to address the challenges posed by the Biden administration.
White House spokesman Kush Desai defended Trump’s economic continuity, stating, “President Trump has been talking about housing, health insurance, and drug pricing reform since he first ran for office in 2015.” Yet, within the GOP ranks, tensions have surfaced regarding some proposals, such as Trump’s readiness to compromise on the Hyde Amendment for bipartisan healthcare reforms.
Costs of Tariffs and Economic Perception
While Trump pushes for an economic comeback, scrutiny arises from his earlier policies. Tariffs established during his first term have contributed to ongoing financial strains for families. A 2025 analysis estimated these tariffs added about $1,700 annually to household expenses—critical information that undermines Trump’s affordability narrative.
Some consumer goods, particularly those impacted by modified trade regulations, have seen price increases. For instance, bananas and coffee faced notable price hikes following trade adjustments under Trump’s administration. Though the administration later lifted tariffs on certain necessities and allocated $12 billion in relief payments, these measures were seen as temporary solutions rather than permanent fixes.
As it stands, current tariff rates hover around 16.8%, a figure unmatched since 1935. Nevertheless, Trump remains adamant about utilizing these tariffs as negotiation tools and economic instruments.
Voter Sentiment and the Economic Landscape
Looking ahead, the question looms as to whether the gradual economic recovery will sway voter attitudes. Trump’s statement regarding Democrats abandoning affordability messaging may hold appeal for voters fatigued by inflation, but many remain doubtful. While gas prices averaging $3.21 indicate a decrease from peak levels, they represent a stark contrast to the Trump-era lows of 2019. Current mortgage rates just above 6% are more manageable than the previous year’s peaks, yet they remain far from the lows of 3% homeowners enjoyed before the pandemic. Grocery bills, though slightly eased, continue to be a pressing concern for families.
In this context, Trump’s narrative offers a claim of economic recovery. His viral tweet encapsulated this idea: “Rent prices down. Mortgage rates down. Inflation slowed. GDP set to explode. Tax refunds SURGING. Prices of many categories of goods down.” While there are indicators that lend some credence to his viewpoint, the economic story is more than just statistics. It fundamentally involves the realities faced in households across the country. Democrats might still be addressing affordability, but the ongoing conversation demonstrates that the economic battleground remains crucial as 2024 approaches.
"*" indicates required fields
