Democrats Surpass 2024 Benchmarks in Early Specials, Raising Questions for 2026 GOP Prospects
Recent special election results indicate that Democrats are outperforming their 2024 baseline by a significant margin, stirring speculation about the implications for Republicans in the upcoming 2026 midterm elections. CNN’s senior political analyst Harry Enten reports that Democrats surpass Vice President Kamala Harris’s performance in 2024 by an impressive 12 percentage points in these contests.
Enten commented, “The data looks a lot like what happened during the 2017 and 2018 cycle,” suggesting current trends could lead to a landscape change similar to when Democrats gained a majority in the House during Donald Trump’s initial presidency. He further pointed out, “Five out of five times, the party that outperforms in the special elections goes on to win the U.S. House of Representatives.”
Democrats’ noteworthy performance appears particularly striking considering they had recently lost control of the White House and both chambers of Congress. While historical patterns favor the party out of power, recent political dynamics and approval ratings introduce uncertainty regarding whether this momentum can be sustained into 2026.
Understanding the 12-Point Surge
This 12-point surge is based on careful calculations from the five special elections conducted thus far in the 2025–2026 cycle, comparing results to Harris’s 2024 performance in the same districts. The consistency of the shift across varied partisan environments has raised considerable interest.
It’s important to note that while Democrats are not winning every race, they are gaining substantial ground, even in districts where they underperformed in 2024. Harris’s campaign struggled to garner support from critical party factions, resulting in a notable loss to Trump. Her vote share was historically low for a Democratic nominee—a headwind that makes the 12-point swing even more significant.
However, a shift from a low starting point doesn’t immediately suggest Democratic dominance. Yet, successful performances in special elections often serve as reliable indicators of voter enthusiasm and turnout for upcoming midterms.
Historical Comparison
Looking back to the 2017 and 2018 election cycles provides valuable context. Following Trump’s victory in 2016, Democrats began winning or closely contesting special elections in predominantly Republican districts. This momentum paved the way for the major gains made during the “blue wave” of 2018 when Democrats flipped 41 seats to reclaim control of the House. Enten’s observation about the consistent special election performance aligning with future outcomes derives from these historical precedents.
However, the current 2025 cycle stands apart due to the heightened degree of Democratic overperformance compared to recent elections. In the 2018 cycle, the overperformance averaged around 10 points, while it has already reached 12 points this early in the cycle.
What’s Driving the Numbers?
There are indications that Republican governance is facing scrutiny, potentially fueling the Democratic surge. Since his inauguration in January 2025, President Trump and the Republican majority have worked to reverse many of the previous administration’s policies, from environmental regulations to social service funding cuts. New trade tariffs have reignited tensions, further complicating public perception.
While Trump remains popular among his base, his overall approval ratings hover between 42% and 45%, with discontent rising among independents. A recent Quinnipiac University poll showed congressional Republicans with just a 36% favorability rating, raised by headlines about budget disputes and administrative changes.
This dissatisfaction may be reflected in the special election outcomes. Early turnout favors Democrats, particularly among younger voters and in suburban districts. It appears Republicans may be experiencing complacency typical of a party in power during early midterm cycles.
Concerns for Republicans
The emerging trend from special elections suggests that Republicans could face challenges in 2026, historically a warning sign for those holding majority status. Significant shifts in the special election landscape have preceded the loss of the House by both parties over the years, as indicated by past electoral outcomes.
“Democrats don’t need a national wave, but they do need to win in the right places,” Enten remarked. “These specials give us a glimpse into where that might happen.”
Should this path continue, Republicans might confront a formidable 2026 election, despite currently holding a majority. While they can capitalize on redrawn district maps and existing fundraising advantages, overconfidence and mixed messaging could lead to vulnerabilities, as seen in previous elections.
Not All Losses Are Created Equal
It’s crucial to understand that “overperformance” does not equate to outright wins for Democrats. Republicans are still securing victories in several special elections, though often by slimmer margins than anticipated. Such trends should raise alarms for any party in control.
Consider a recent special election in a solidly Republican Southern district: the Republican winner clinched a 7-point margin, down from a 19-point loss that Harris suffered there in 2024. That shift of 12 points signals tension for GOP strategists moving into upcoming elections.
The Big Picture
Democrats need a net gain of just nine seats to regain the House. In 2024, Republicans expanded their majority by winning 17 vulnerable seats, many decided by narrow margins. Sustaining a 12-point swing could make those Democratic targets achievable again, especially in suburban locales where GOP lead margins were already slim.
However, uncertainties loom. Economic fluctuations, international issues, and legislative changes could influence public opinion leading up to November 2026. The early signs reveal a potential shift, but durability of this trend relies on factors such as turnout, candidate quality, and party cohesion.
Currently, the Democratic overperformance in special elections serves as a salient warning. History has proven that ignoring such trends carries risks, and as Enten aptly stated, “Five out of five times, the party that outperforms in the special elections goes on to win the U.S. House.”
"*" indicates required fields
