California Governor Gavin Newsom has provided abundant fodder for criticism, particularly regarding his handling of education and race. His remarks during a recent book tour stop in Atlanta have sparked outrage, revealing more about his political pandering than any genuine connection to the issues faced by minority communities. In front of an audience of predominantly Black citizens, Newsom mused that his 960 SAT score made him relatable to the crowd. “I’m just trying to impress upon you, I’m like you. I’m no better than you,” he stated, seemingly unaware of how tone-deaf his comments were.
This bizarre self-comparison raises questions about Newsom’s understanding of the educational challenges many face, especially in light of real data showing disparities in literacy rates. Mississippi Governor Tate Reeves seized the opportunity to remind Newsom that Black students in his state are significantly more likely to read proficiently than those in California. “A Black student in Mississippi is 2.5 times more likely to read proficiently by 4th grade than if he or she lived in California,” Reeves pointed out. His response neatly encapsulated the ongoing struggle of education policy in California compared to the strides being made in Mississippi.
Newsom’s admission of his dyslexia while attempting to connect with his audience garnered mixed reactions. While dyslexia is a legitimate challenge, it does not excuse him from the responsibility of effective leadership. Instead of addressing systemic issues, his comments reflect a pattern of identity politics that seems more focused on optics than concrete action. By presenting himself as a “960 SAT guy,” Newsom diminishes the real struggles of countless students grappling with educational inequities.
The irony is striking. As Newsom attempts to align himself with the community, he simultaneously highlights a disconnect from the alarming educational outcomes in his own state. Mississippi has undergone a remarkable transformation, dubbed the “Mississippi Miracle,” moving up from nearly last in the nation to a commendable ranking in fourth-grade reading scores in just over a decade. This success is attributed to robust phonics programs and a commitment to high educational standards. Meanwhile, California’s performance lags behind, particularly for Black students.
Reeves did not miss the chance to underscore this gap. He offered to send reading coaches to California, suggesting that Newsom might benefit from their expertise. “Learning is a lifelong journey,” Reeves said, implying that Newsom could use a lesson in genuine leadership that prioritizes educational outcomes over self-serving narratives.
Newsom’s defensive response to his critics, particularly his profanity-laden retort directed at Fox News’ Sean Hannity, further illustrates his precarious political footing. Instead of engaging constructively with the concerns raised about his remarks, he opted for vulgarity as a means of measuring his passion. He claimed that critics were “fake outraged” about his struggles, but such a response does little to address the substantive issues presented by his comments. It signals a retreat into divisive rhetoric rather than a step toward accountability.
As debates about identity and education continue, it’s essential to focus on what truly matters: the education of children. It’s disheartening to witness a leader prioritize personal narratives over solutions that can help minority students. The stark reality is that parents do not care whether a governor claims to empathize with them if he is not delivering results in education.
Ultimately, Newsom’s recent comments reveal more about the pitfalls of identity politics than they do about genuine understanding or leadership. As Mississippi sets a standard for improving literacy among its students, California remains stuck in a cycle of political theatrics. The questions raised by this discourse indicate a pressing need for leaders to focus on tangible achievements rather than superficial connections.
The difference in outcomes between Mississippi and California emphasizes that effective education reform requires more than rhetoric. It demands relentless effort and a commitment to systemic change. Newsom’s narrative paints a picture of a leader more invested in appearances and personal struggles, rather than the pressing needs of his constituents. If he’s serious about making a positive impact, a course correction is in order.
"*" indicates required fields
