The recent shooting incident in Pawtucket, Rhode Island, during a high school hockey game echoes a troubling trend intersecting violence and transgender identities. On a day when two lives were lost and three others were injured, details regarding the shooter—Robert Dorgan, also known as Roberta Esposito—emerged slowly in reports, appearing much later in the coverage than the initial facts of the tragedy.
According to reports, Dorgan entered the arena to watch a game involving a family member, leading to gunfire that Chief Tina Goncalves characterized as a targeted event stemming from a family dispute. This shooting follows a disturbing pattern. Just a week earlier, the tragic actions of another transgender individual, Jesse Van Rootselaar, raised similar issues in Canada when he took the lives of family members and those in his school.
The media’s hesitance to directly report on the identities of transgender shooters is increasingly evident. In the case of Van Rootselaar, Reuters referred to the shooter as female while law enforcement described him in a manner that many viewed as vague and misleading. Such caution in label usage suggests an underlying reluctance to connect transgender identity with violent acts. This pattern highlights a delicate but essential debate in the public discourse surrounding violence and mental health.
Following the Pawtucket shooting, the Daily Mail noted concerning behavior from Dorgan prior to the event. An account believed to belong to him hinted at a dangerous mindset, suggesting that he was on the edge. His ominous message on social media—”Keep bashing us, but do not wonder why we go BESERK”—is particularly striking. It reflects not just the individual struggles but also a growing sense of frustration felt in various communities.
Adding complexity to this narrative, a woman identified as Dorgan’s daughter pointed out that her father had mental health issues. Her statement provided crucial context regarding his actions. “He shot my family, and he’s dead now,” she said, implying a need for compassion amidst horror. Dorgan’s ex-wife also noted troubling traits, indicating a history that may have contributed to the violence that unfolded. The presence of both mental health struggles and family dynamics can’t be ignored when trying to understand the motives behind such tragedies.
This incident is not isolated. Several high-profile shootings involving transgender-identifying individuals have occurred over the past few years. The heartbreaking incident in Nashville, where Audrey Hale killed six people before taking her own life, is another example, alongside the Minneapolis church shooting by Robert Westman. A 2025 analysis from The Western Journal revealed that a significant number—about 40 percent—of planned or executed mass school shootings since 2020 involved transgender-identifying shooters. These statistics bring forth serious concerns about societal and systemic factors fueling this type of violence.
In summary, the events in Pawtucket mark yet another chapter in a deeply troubling narrative. The repeated appearance of transgender individuals in violent incidents raises critical questions about mental health, societal pressures, and the media’s role in framing these narratives. As investigations continue and more information comes to light, it’s vital to approach the topic with care and an understanding of the complexities involved.
"*" indicates required fields
