Tom Homan, the Trump Administration’s Border Czar, offered a sharp critique of Pope Leo XIV’s comments on immigration during a recent media exchange. Homan expressed a desire for the pope to engage directly with him rather than listen to former Obama strategist David Axelrod, emphasizing the need for a conversation centered on border security and public safety. He pointedly remarked, “I wish they’d sit down with me and hear my experiences,” contending that such dialogue could help the church understand the critical role of a secure border.
The pope has articulated a stance that prioritizes compassion for long-term residents living outside their home countries. He stated, “When people are living good lives… to treat them in a way that is extremely disrespectful… I think that the bishops have been very clear.” However, this viewpoint does not align with Homan’s perspective. He took issue with this approach, particularly when reflecting on the penalties for illegal border crossing. He noted, “If we jumped the wall at the Vatican, the penalties for doing that are much harder than the ones here in the United States.”
Homan, a lifelong member of the Catholic Church, expressed frustration that the institution is engaging in political discourse rather than addressing its internal challenges. “I love the Catholic Church. I just wish they’d stick to fixing the church,” he stated. His concerns extend to the remarks made by three cardinals who recently condemned the Trump Administration’s immigration policies, suggesting they misunderstand the consequences of those policies. “They think Trump policies are inhumane and ICE is a rogue agency,” Homan asserted.
Statistics from Homan note a significant decline in illegal immigration under Trump’s administration, with a reported 97% decrease. He linked border security to improved safety outcomes, raising critical questions about the dangers faced by individuals trying to cross unlawfully. “How many women aren’t being abused…? How many people aren’t dying making that journey?” he pressed. Homan presented stark evidence of the dangers posed during the Biden administration, highlighting that “over 4,000 died,” attributing many of these tragedies to the lack of border security and the rampant narcotics crisis with a “historic record” of fentanyl-related deaths in America.
In his view, establishing a secure border is not just a matter of law enforcement; it is a humanitarian imperative. “The most vulnerable people in the world are going to give their life savings to the cartels to make that dangerous journey,” he explained. For Homan, the message to the Vatican is clear: “Secure borders save lives.” He believes that personal experiences, particularly those involving tragic incidents related to illegal crossings, would profoundly affect perspectives if shared with church leaders. He recounted heart-wrenching scenarios, wishing those in positions of influence could understand both the societal and human toll of illegal immigration.
Homan concluded by inviting dialogue, insisting that “illegal immigration is not a victimless crime.” He claimed, “Human traffickers are out of business, right? The cartels are going bankrupt because of that secure border.” In this context, he argues for a reevaluation of compassion that prioritizes the safety and well-being of society, particularly the most vulnerable, over an open-border approach.
Overall, Homan’s commentary underscores a deeply held conviction that border security is intrinsically tied to public safety and humanitarian concerns. His calls for conversation with those in authority reflect a desire for an informed discussion that could bridge understanding between differing viewpoints on immigration policy.
"*" indicates required fields
