President Nayib Bukele’s portrayal of El Salvador’s transformation offers a striking picture of a nation reborn. He attributes the dramatic changes to divine intervention, insisting, “It was the hand of God. And no one can doubt it!” His words resonate in a country that, until recently, grappled with some of the highest homicide rates globally. This narrative not only rallies his supporters but also seeks to lend legitimacy to his policy decisions.
The centerpiece of Bukele’s claim is the staggering decrease in murders, from nearly 4,000 in 2017 to fewer than 80 in early 2024. “Transforming that, the most dangerous country in the world, into what it is today, is the clearest miracle,” he said, adding that this change provides “proof” of a significant shift. For many Salvadorans, those statistics are more than numbers; they symbolize a tangible shift toward safety in their daily lives.
However, peeling back the layers of this so-called miracle reveals deeper issues tied to the state’s heavy hand. The security improvements come under a draconian “state of exception” that has been in place for over two years, bypassing constitutional norms. Critics highlight serious human rights concerns arising from this approach—mass detentions and political repression are part of the landscape, indicating the toll on individual freedoms that accompany the government’s control measures. Thousands are behind bars without formal charges or legal representation, raising alarm about the state of justice in the nation.
Conditions in prisons are concerning, with many detainees subjected to harsh environments and a lack of oversight. Reports indicate that policing tactics driven by quotas lead to wrongful accusations, fueling a climate of fear. Among those paying the price for Bukele’s policies are the very people who sought safety, forced into a system where due process seems increasingly out of reach.
Despite these concerns, Bukele’s popularity remains intact. His approval ratings reflect a society eager for change after years of turmoil. He was re-elected in 2024, and the narrative surrounding him as the architect of El Salvador’s newfound security is now widespread. External opinions, such as those from Colombian media describing him as a “model for regional security,” bolster his standing in the eyes of supporters who longed for peace amid chaos.
Moving beyond security, Bukele has set his sights on transforming the nation’s economic narrative. “Our next step is to ensure that the world perceives El Salvador more for its economic miracle than for its security miracle,” he remarked. His administration is aggressively pitching the country as an investment hub, promoting initiatives that include major infrastructural projects and tourism development. The adoption of Bitcoin as legal tender is a particularly ambitious move intended to position El Salvador as a forward-thinking economic player.
However, the reality is more nuanced. Economic forecasts by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund indicate that El Salvador may face the worst growth rate in Central America by 2025. While certain indications of improvement exist—like decreased extortion and increasing business confidence—many farmers remain economically stifled by persistent structural challenges that hinder progress.
The government’s relationship with international financial institutions has soured. Critics argue that Bukele’s strategies, including the gamble on Bitcoin, have strained traditional partnerships, creating potential pitfalls for future financial stability. Public projects funded by foreign countries, particularly China, have been criticized for lacking sustainable benefits, leading opponents to warn about escalating national debt tied to these ventures.
Internally, Bukele has consolidated his grip on power, dismantling checks and balances designed to safeguard democracy. His controversial decisions, such as purging the Supreme Court and destroying the Monument of Reconciliation, aim to reshape El Salvador’s narrative. “I’m giving birth to this country!” Bukele’s grandiose claims are echoed in commentary from journalists, outlining the extent of his control over the nation’s identity.
Despite widespread human rights issues, many Salvadorans appear willing to overlook these concerns. They measure success in the plummeting murder rates and changes to their daily existence. To them, Bukele’s declaration of a miracle can seem believable given their experiences of violence and turmoil. Yet, this acceptance raises questions about the sacrifices made for peace—what lengths people will go to attain stability.
As El Salvador navigates this transformative period, it stands at a critical crossroads. The short-term security gains are juxtaposed against the growing realities of economic stagnation and diminished freedoms. International observers express apprehension that Bukele’s narrative risks concealing a significant authoritarian trend beneath the surface.
In Bukele’s eyes, the miracle remains unexplainable—“There is no one who can come and explain how it happened.” It is a powerful statement, leaving unanswered questions about the nation’s trajectory. For now, the streets may be quiet, with flags waving high above places once inundated with fear, but the underlying issues suggest that El Salvador’s path ahead is far from clear.
"*" indicates required fields
