Will Poulter, the British actor known for his appearances in major films, has reignited discussions around U.S. immigration and national identity with recent statements shared in an interview with Variety. He expressed dismay that Americans seem to overlook their immigrant roots, stating, “It’s really upsetting to see people forget that we’re a country that we have immigrants to thank for.” While Poulter’s comments resonate with the narrative of America as a land of opportunity, they fail to engage with the reality of ongoing border concerns and immigration policy challenges.
The United States is currently experiencing a significant surge in immigration, with the foreign-born population reaching a record high of 45.3 million in 2021, according to the Pew Research Center. The Department of Homeland Security indicates these numbers have only grown, exacerbated by increased encounters at the Southern border. Poulter, highlighting the contributions of immigrants, overlooks the widespread anxieties among Americans about these rapid changes in demographics and the strain on public resources.
Poulter’s comment, “It’s really upsetting to see people forget…,” taps into a common theme found in statements from Hollywood and European politicians alike. Yet, it comes amid some of the highest rates of border encounters in history—over 2.2 million documented by U.S. Customs and Border Protection in fiscal year 2023. This escalation has drawn sharp criticism of the Biden administration for perceived failures in managing border security and immigration flows.
Recent polling underscores this discontent. A September 2023 survey by Pew revealed that immigration ranks as a top issue among registered voters, with a substantial portion of respondents—80% of Republicans and 37% of Democrats—rating government performance on immigration as “poor.” This growing bipartisan concern highlights a disconnect between the perspectives of those in the entertainment industry and the realities faced by working and middle-class Americans, particularly those living near border communities.
Online reactions to Poulter’s statement reflect this tension. Many supporters appreciate his recognition of multiculturalism, while others question whether a foreign actor can grasp the complexities of U.S. immigration policy. As one commenter pointed out, “Actors can afford to say things like that. They don’t live near the border; they don’t wait in line at ERs with undocumented migrants filling up rooms; they don’t see wages driven down.” Such exchanges illustrate the struggle between different experiences and interpretations of immigration in America.
The transformation of the U.S. immigration system in the last four decades has been profound. The number of immigrants rose from fewer than 15 million in 1980 to over 45 million today. This change is largely attributed to globalization and civil unrest, but critics point to the social costs and enforcement gaps as pressing concerns. The Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) estimated that illegal immigration costs U.S. taxpayers approximately $150.7 billion annually, a figure that raises alarms about the sustainability of public services.
Debates about immigration’s impact on the labor market continue to be fiercely contested. Advocates argue that immigrants fulfill essential roles in various sectors, while reports indicate that low-skilled immigration may suppress wages in certain industries. However, a Congressional Budget Office report suggests that, overall, immigration contributes positively to the economic landscape, countering an aging population.
The disconnect between urban elites and rural Americans is further highlighted by a Gallup poll showing that 63% of Americans were dissatisfied with current immigration levels—the highest dissatisfaction rating in twenty years. This reflects a significant shift in attitudes, with a marked rise in discontent in just two years.
Poulter’s remarks resonate amid the UK’s own immigration challenges post-Brexit, where net migration has reached record heights. Critics there argue that rising immigration strains public services and social cohesion. Both the U.S. and the UK grapple with public expectations for effective immigration policies, balancing humanitarian responsibilities against practical constraints.
Despite the Biden administration’s issuance of temporary protections and expanded admissions for refugees, challenges remain. The decision to end Title 42 expulsions has led to congested border facilities and lengthy immigration court waits, with over 3 million cases pending in U.S. courts as of late 2023.
Poulter’s heartfelt assertions about the immigrant foundation of America unfold against this complex backdrop. His statement that “we’re a country that we have immigrants to thank for” certainly carries historical weight. Yet, critics stress that the American narrative also involves the principles of order and secure borders, which many believe are being compromised by ongoing policy failures.
The immigration debate is rife with contention. Advocates for reduced immigration point to overwhelmed public systems, security concerns, and pressures on wages. Conversely, proponents of increased immigration urge for programs that acknowledge labor demands across numerous sectors.
For many Americans, the core issue is not whether immigrants have contributed to the nation’s development, but whether current immigration practices reflect a balanced, enforceable, and secure approach to immigration. As this discussion continues, the gap between varying perspectives on immigration remains wide, revealing the complexities that will need to be addressed to forge a cohesive path ahead.
"*" indicates required fields
