The recent death of Nemesio Rubén Oseguera Cervantes, known as “El Mencho,” has sparked discussions about its impact on the global drug trade. While the removal of a CEO in traditional business often causes market turmoil, the effects of eliminating a drug cartel leader are notably different. The circumstances surrounding El Mencho’s demise highlight the resilience of cartels in a way that contradicts conventional economic expectations.
When a key player in the drug trade is taken out, the assumption might be that supply will be disrupted, leading to increased prices. However, drug prices have remained stable despite a history of kingpin arrests and military interventions. This paradox raises important questions about the structure of these criminal organizations. According to Tom Wainwright in his book “Narconomics: How to Run a Drug Cartel,” cartels are not vulnerable like traditional firms. They operate more like decentralized corporations designed to withstand shocks such as the death of a leader.
The Jalisco New Generation Cartel, under El Mencho’s leadership, exemplifies this structural robustness. When leadership changes occur, the operations continue without a hitch. This continuity means disruption is minimal, leaving the market largely unaffected. The way cartels are organized allows them to quickly replace leadership and maintain control over their distribution networks.
Wainwright further illustrates that cartels wield significant power over their entire supply chain, especially regarding coca farmers. In a normal market dynamic, farmers would be able to negotiate prices based on supply and demand. However, in regions dominated by violent conflict, often only one trafficking group holds sway over coca leaf prices. As a result, these cartels dictate lower prices to farmers, even in a climate of scarcity.
The power imbalance is striking. The lack of competition allows cartels to insulate themselves from rising costs, much like large retailers do with their suppliers. This approach not only stabilizes cartel profits but also keeps the financial burdens placed on farmers. As Wainwright noted, when conditions for coca cultivation worsen, “any worsening in coca-growing conditions simply makes poor farmers even poorer.” The consequences of cartel dominance accumulate without significantly affecting the price of cocaine for consumers.
In summary, the assassination of a cartel leader disrupts the leadership hierarchy yet fails to destabilize the operational infrastructure that maintains market equilibrium. The Jalisco New Generation Cartel, like others, demonstrates an inherent resilience that challenges conventional economic reasoning. By maintaining tight control over supply chains and leveraging their power over farmers, cartels ensure their profitability remains robust, even in the face of significant leadership losses. The death of a kingpin, therefore, signals little more than a shuffle at the top while allowing the broader system to function as usual.
"*" indicates required fields
