Dalia Ziada, a scholar who fled Egypt due to her criticisms of Hamas, delivers a stark warning about the dangers of alliances between the far left and Islamist extremism. As a coordinator at the Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy, Ziada’s insights carry weight in the current global context. She warns that the dynamics seen in the United States echo the calamitous events that unfolded in Iran in 1979, when an Islamic regime seized control after the left allied with Islamists.
Ziada observes that today’s coordinated protests, labeled “Nakba 78,” utilize the anniversary of Israel’s founding to challenge the legitimacy of the Jewish state. She argues these demonstrations suggest a troubling partnership between radical left groups and Islamist factions, a relationship she describes as a “sinful marriage.” Over recent years, this coalition has capitalized on the Palestinian cause to forge connections with various activist movements across the West.
She mentions groups linked to the Muslim Brotherhood that have relentlessly sought to mobilize support against the West. The ideologies within these movements intersect, driven by a mutual desire to dismantle Western liberal democracies. Ziada articulates, “They agree on one thing: they need to destroy the West as we know it today and replace it with something else.” This sweeping ambition speaks to a larger issue: the potential fracturing of alliances when extreme factions assert dominance after gaining power.
Recent investigations identified around 425 organizations interconnected within a transnational protest network. This network encompasses various groups—including communist entities and anti-Israel coalitions—with annual revenues nearing $1 billion. By organizing nearly 736 events across 39 countries, these groups capitalize on current events to further their agendas, particularly following the intensified violence in Gaza after the Hamas attacks on October 7. Ziada notes that the war has provided “a moral umbrella” for the movement, allowing its members to justify their actions under the guise of legitimacy.
Drawing parallels with the Iranian Revolution, Ziada reflects on how the left was initially drawn in by a promise of progressive change but ultimately became expendable in the eyes of the Islamists once power shifted. “They allied with the communists there, made them believe that we all are going to change Iran and make it a better place,” she recalls. The ultimate outcome saw the communists sacrificed by the very regime they helped to install, a lesson that could echo in the United States should similar alliances be allowed to deepen.
Protests are expected to follow traditional patterns of anti-Israel sentiment. Ziada believes the rhetoric used will likely invoke terms like “apartheid” and “genocide,” pointing to a broader, cohesive alignment among participating groups. In her analysis, the term “Nakba,” originally used to address the failures of Arab leaders, has morphed into a rallying cry against Israel, stripping its original context and emphasizing a modern agenda focused on undermining Western values.
For Ziada, the implications are deeply personal. Having witnessed the disintegration of her homeland, she expresses a profound concern for the future of the United States, a country she regards as a sanctuary and a place of opportunity. “I’ve seen my native Egypt being destroyed by these groups, by these people,” she asserts. “I don’t want to see the United States… being destroyed by the same bad guys.” This plea underscores the high stakes involved in ideological movements that may seem aligned today but harbor fundamentally incompatible goals.
Ziada’s warnings resonate at a crucial junction. As protests emerge, it is crucial to consider the underlying motivations and the potential for divisions fueled by extreme ideologies. If lessons from history teach us anything, it’s that cooperation among disparate groups may not withstand the test of time, especially when power is realized and conflicts of interest emerge. The call for vigilance against the encroachment of such alliances is loud and clear.
"*" indicates required fields
