Jonathan Bush, a Republican running for governor of Maine, is facing scrutiny over his past as the head of a network of birthing clinics in San Diego County. These clinics primarily served migrant women, a fact that has resurfaced as he competes for the Republican nomination ahead of the June 9 primary. In a 2014 book, he noted that Athena Women’s Health, which he co-founded, catered mostly to low-income clients. He said, “We needed their business and even appealed to them with Spanish-language ads on local TV.”
At one point, Bush claimed his clinics were responsible for thousands of births annually. “We were doing 3,000 babies a year,” he recalled on the Venture Fizz Podcast in 2022. This detail raises questions about the nature of his services, especially as he campaigns on a platform that includes strong immigration reform.
Bush has pushed back against claims regarding Athena’s role in facilitating access to citizenship for children of undocumented immigrants. In a response to inquiries, his campaign insisted that Athenahealth provided healthcare software solutions, not direct medical services. “They have never provided any medical services of any kind,” Bush said. He emphasizes his alignment with President Trump’s stance on immigration, stating, “Illegal immigrants should be deported.”
However, evidence indicates that the clinics were indeed involved with birthing services at a time when Bush was actively managing the business. A profile from 2005 highlighted the early days of their main clinic and described the immediate joy of welcoming newborns into the world. The Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity also categorizes Bush’s work with Athena as operating a birthing clinic.
From Bush’s own accounts, it appears that a significant portion of his client base comprised migrant women. He recalled, “A lot of low-income families had to pay cash — migrant laborers, all kinds of people.” As the business grew, he suggested that Athena struggled financially, largely due to its high percentage of low-income clients. “Our popularity worked against us,” Bush stated, describing how the clinic evolved to serve those without proper insurance who sought low-cost medical services.
As he seeks to establish himself as a pro-business candidate for Maine, Bush must contend with perceptions of his past involvement with immigrant populations. His competitor, Bobby Charles, harshly critiques Bush for his previous ties to migrant services. Charles stated, “The contrast couldn’t be clearer. I am a pro-Trump conservative who will remove illegals out of the state.”
Bush’s experiences and comments reflect a complex narrative as he navigates the political landscape, balancing business accomplishments against emerging critiques about his history with immigrant populations. The urgency of the upcoming primary may amplify these discussions, as Bush’s past could shape voters’ perceptions in this decisive moment.
"*" indicates required fields
