Just weeks before President Donald Trump federalized the Washington, D.C., police force due to escalating crime, serious allegations emerged involving the Metropolitan Police Department. The police union chair, Gregg Pemberton, accused the department of manipulating crime statistics to present a more favorable image. “When our members respond to the scene of a felony offense, inevitably… there will be a lieutenant or a captain that will show up and direct those members to take a report for a lesser offense,” he told NBC Washington. This practice allegedly downplayed serious crimes like shootings and stabbings, instead categorizing them as minor thefts or injuries.
These accusations followed the suspension of police commander Michael Pulliam, who reportedly altered crime data in his district. Pulliam, who has denied the allegations, filed an employment complaint against higher-ups shortly before his suspension. The Metropolitan Police Department, when asked for updates, stated it would not comment on internal investigations.
Amid this controversy, Trump’s federalization of the police department prompted widespread responses. He invoked Section 740 of the District of Columbia Home Rule Act to assume control, stating, “Our capital city has been overtaken by violent gangs and bloodthirsty criminals… and we’re not going to let it happen anymore.” The president emphasized that restoring law and order was critical, pledging to deploy National Guard troops to assist local law enforcement.
In contrast, liberal leaders quickly criticized Trump, asserting that crime rates had reached a 30-year low. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries emphasized the lack of justification for Trump’s takeover, while former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton labeled him as “unhinged” for his concerns about crime in D.C.
Crime statistics tell a complicated story. Reports showed that despite a recent decrease in crime rates, the lethality of violent incidents had surged. A study found that Washington, D.C., now has the highest lethality rate among major cities, with a significant rise in homicides compared to previous years. Jillian Snider, a former NYPD officer, noted, “You have less chance of being victimized, but if you are victimized, you have more of a chance of dying.”
As the police union supports Trump’s intervention and pushes back against the narrative of declining crime, they argue that issues persist. Pemberton expressed agreement with the president, stating, “Crime in the district is out of control and something needs to be done about it.” The debate over crime in Washington, D.C., reflects broader tensions between those seeking to address public safety and those challenging the narrative of improvement.
"*" indicates required fields
