The Diocese of Charlotte in North Carolina is facing scrutiny following a troubling internal memo that outlines a strategy aimed at silencing dissent among Catholics regarding the Traditional Latin Mass (TLM). The memo, titled “Traditionis Custodes Implementation in the Diocese of Charlotte 2025: Responses to Concerns,” has sparked controversy after it was published by Catholic scholar Dr. Peter Kwasniewski on social media.
On May 23, 2025, Bishop Michael T. Martin announced significant changes planned for the diocese, including the closure of all four parish TLMs, which will be consolidated into a single location—a former Protestant church in Mooresville—effective July 8. The bishop cites Pope Francis’ 2021 directives in the document as the basis for these sweeping changes. However, many believe this approach is not about “Church unity,” as proclaimed, but rather an overt attempt to quash the longstanding traditions that many faithful Catholics hold dear.
The internal memo presents a tone that seems to undermine the concerns of the congregation. It admits that the suppression of the TLM will be “painful for our faithful” but goes on to assert that Pope Francis was well aware of the emotional toll it would take. This duality illustrates a dismissive attitude toward those who cherish the TLM. The bishops appear to adopt tactics of gaslighting, with the memo instructing clergy on how to maintain control over narratives within their congregations.
Responses to potential objections from the community are met with condescension. The memo states, “Listening and agreeing aren’t the same thing,” implying a lack of genuine engagement with the concerns of parishioners. Bishop Martin insists that he genuinely “cares deeply” for the Catholics in western North Carolina, yet offers no substantial rationale for dismantling their beloved liturgies. This disconnect strikes at the core of trust within the diocese.
As the backlash grew—both from local parishioners and Catholics internationally—the bishop paused the immediate implementation of his original plans. On June 22, facing increasing pressure, Bishop Martin decided to postpone the crackdown on TLM until the Vatican’s deadline of October 2, instead of the previously set July 8. This delay was a response to a letter from four parish priests expressing their concerns. The decision illustrates the power of community voice, showing that organized pushback can lead to temporary reprieves from harsh measures.
In light of these developments, Regina Magazine has announced an upcoming documentary titled *Bread Not Stones*, which highlights the personal stories of Catholics who fear losing their connection to the TLM. The film serves as a poignant recount of what has transpired in the Diocese of Charlotte and aims to shed light on the broader impact of ecclesiastical policies that misinterpret the faithful’s deep-seated love for traditional practices.
The dedication of this documentary to “all parishes throughout the world” affected by similar suppression resonates with individuals who feel their spiritual lives are under siege. The filmmakers seek to illustrate not just the immediate consequences of these policy changes but also the lasting damage inflicted upon communities who have cherished their liturgies for generations.
Overall, the unfolding conflict in Charlotte is emblematic of a broader struggle within the Church: the tension between authority and tradition. As decisions continue to unfold, the faithful in North Carolina and beyond remain vigilant, aware of the potential implications these changes hold for their future. The concerns raised are not merely administrative; they strike at the heart of identity and tradition within the Catholic faith.
"*" indicates required fields
