A federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., has intervened in a contentious legal battle involving the removal of an independent agency member appointed during the Biden administration. On Tuesday, a three-judge panel ruled 2-1 that FTC Commissioner Rebecca Slaughter’s firing by former President Donald Trump could not stand, citing established Supreme Court precedent. This ruling comes as part of a broader discussion regarding presidential authority to dismiss members of independent agencies without cause.
The judges stated, “The government has no likelihood of success on appeal given controlling and directly on point Supreme Court precedent.” This reinforces the notion that lower court decisions must adhere to Supreme Court guidelines. Slaughter’s case reached the appellate court after she was abruptly removed following Trump’s inauguration. She was reinstated by Judge Loren AliKhan in July, only to be let go once again when the appellate court briefly paused that decision.
By lifting the pause on AliKhan’s order, the appeals court has now cleared the way for Slaughter to return to her position. However, the Trump administration retains the option to appeal this latest ruling. Department of Justice attorneys voiced their concerns, arguing that the appellate court’s reinstatement of Slaughter contradicts relevant Supreme Court rulings that had previously limited similar reinstatements. They contend that allowing her to maintain her role while the matter is debated “works a grave harm to the separation of powers and the President’s ability to exercise his authority under the Constitution.”
This legal decision has significant implications for the balance of power within the government, particularly regarding the independence of regulatory agencies. The conflict exemplifies the broader tensions between different branches of government and highlights the complexities surrounding the executive’s power profile. As this story develops, the outcomes could reshape how independent agencies operate in relation to presidential authority.
"*" indicates required fields
