In a revealing moment from a congressional hearing during Trump’s first term, Tom Homan, then-ICE director, faced off against Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) concerning immigration policy. The clip, which has resurfaced, highlights the tensions between strict enforcement and humanitarian concerns surrounding immigration.
Homan defended the controversial “zero-tolerance” policy, which aimed at strict penalization for illegal border crossings. He likened the separation of children from parents involved in immigration violations to situations where abusive parents are removed from their children. Homan’s stance is clear: violating U.S. immigration law under Code 1325 has consequences.
During the exchange, Ocasio-Cortez launched into an emotional tirade, referencing international human rights laws. “So we as members of the United Nations signed on to an international human rights agreement, saying very clearly that family separation is a violation of international human rights,” she stated. She declared, “we pursued a policy that violates human rights,” questioning how the situation had escalated.
Responding to the representative, Homan acknowledged his signature on a memo that recommended the prosecution of all amenable adults crossing the border illegally. He asserted, “I signed that memo,” indicating his commitment to the enforcement policy. Ocasio-Cortez, however, criticized him for what she perceived as an endorsement of family separation. “But it says here that you read, you gave her numerous options, but the recommendation was option three, family separation,” she lamented.
Homan didn’t back down. He explained, “I’m saying this is not the only paper where we’ve given the secretary numerous options to secure the border and save lives.” His insistence on the legality and necessity of the zero-tolerance stance stood firm against Ocasio-Cortez’s characterizations. He reminded her, “If I get arrested for DUI and I have a young child in a car, I’m gonna be separated. When I was a police officer in New York, and I arrested a father for domestic violence, I separated that father from the family.”
Amid Ocasio-Cortez’s assertions about legal asylum seekers not committing crimes, Homan countered with the law: “When you’re in the country illegally, it’s a violation of United States Code, 1325.” His calm and straightforward responses highlighted the clash of ideologies between law enforcement and advocacy for immigration rights.
Towards the end of the exchange, Ocasio-Cortez attempted to reclaim control, stating, “Seeking asylum is legal.” Homan responded unequivocally, insisting, “If you want to seek asylum, go to the port of entry. Do it the legal way.” The debate illustrated the deeper questions at play regarding the balance of security and compassion in U.S. immigration policy.
This confrontation encapsulates the ongoing struggle over immigration enforcement in America, with Homan advocating strict adherence to the law and Ocasio-Cortez arguing for a more lenient, humanitarian approach. Their exchange not only reflects individual beliefs but also the broader ideological divide affecting national discourse around immigration.
"*" indicates required fields
