Illinois Democrats are firmly opposing President Donald Trump’s efforts to bring the National Guard to Chicago. Despite rising crime and a staffing crisis in the Chicago Police Department, local leaders are resisting federal assistance. “No federal troops in the city of Chicago, no militarized force in the city of Chicago,” declared Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson during a protest on Labor Day. The mayor emphasized his commitment to “defending democracy” and “protecting the humanity of every single person” in the city.
Crime in Chicago has long been a pressing issue, with spikes in violence documented since 2020. Over the years, the city has experienced notable crime waves, particularly during holiday weekends, alongside emerging trends of smash-and-grab thefts and illegal street racing. Staffing shortages in the police department can be traced back to increased anti-police sentiments arising from the “defund the police” movement, which gained momentum after the tragic police-involved death of George Floyd in 2020. Current statistics spotlight a grim reality—over 2,000 fewer officers compared to pre-pandemic levels. Data shows the police force peaked at 13,353 sworn officers in 2019 but has since struggled. As of July 2025, the police department has only 11,602 sworn members, while the city budget anticipates a needed 13,742.
In a striking contrast, crime overall has decreased in Chicago since the beginning of this year. City data indicates a 21.6% reduction in crime as of late August compared to the same period last year. The homicide rate, too, reflected this decline, sitting at 17.4 homicides per 100,000 people—the city still less dangerous than others like Memphis, which recorded a rate of 40.6 per 100,000. Yet, the staffing crisis remains acute.
Amid these tensions, the ramifications of the police shortage have become evident. Calls to 911 have gone unanswered, with reports highlighting that over 50% of high-priority calls did not receive immediate police response due to staffing limitations in 2023. This compares starkly to the 19% rate of high-priority calls unanswered in 2019, before the staffing drop-off.
Local news reports have detailed harrowing accounts of inadequate police responses, such as a night when several high-priority incidents—like domestic disturbances and active fights—went unattended due to officers being dispatched elsewhere. The policing challenges have led to a staggering overtime cost of $210.5 million last year—a stark increase from previous years.
Both Johnson and Illinois Governor JB Pritzker have pushed back against Trump’s calls for federal intervention. Pritzker dismissed the idea of deploying additional troops as unnecessary, asserting that local initiatives to counter crime have gained traction. Emphasizing community interventions, he argued that investments made at the community level are effective and maintaining stability in Chicago.
In stark contrast, Trump has not hesitated to highlight the grave situation in Chicago. Citing disturbing statistics from violent weekends, he noted, “Do you know how many people were killed in Chicago last weekend? Eight. You know how many people were killed the week before? Seven.” He framed his commitment to protect American citizens as an obligation, questioning the city’s current approach to law enforcement.
As tensions mount, Chicago saw protests against potential crackdowns on crime recently. These demonstrations included voices against the administration’s attempts to deport illegal immigrants, revealing the layered complexities of the city’s crime dialogue.
In the clash of narratives surrounding Chicago’s law-and-order debate, the city’s leaders staunchly declare their independence from federal oversight. However, the stark realities of crime, public safety, and police staffing illuminate the ongoing struggle to address the very issues at play. As local officials affirm their strategies, observers will be left to consider whether these measures flourish or falter. The city’s future hangs in the balance, caught between political will and public safety.
"*" indicates required fields
