In a recent discussion, Charlie Kirk addressed the growing trend of homeschooling amid criticism from its opponents. When asked about the stereotypes surrounding homeschooled children, he confidently stated that one day, critics may find themselves seeking employment under those very students. He described homeschooled children using a powerful list of attributes: “more polite, smarter, wiser, happier, more purposeful, less corrupted, more understanding, more battle-ready, better prepared, less confused, more biblical, more grounded, more Christ-like.” This portrayal gives insight into the optimism surrounding homeschooling and its potential future impact on society.
The debate over homeschooling isn’t just about education; it reflects a broader struggle between conservative Christians advocating for educational freedom and those on the political left advocating for state control over educational content. Currently, home education reaches about 5–6 percent of school-age children in this country, with parents opting for it due to reasons like religious freedom, academic engagement, safety, personalized educational approaches, and reinforced family relationships.
Research backs the effectiveness of homeschooling. Many studies indicate that homeschooled students score significantly higher on standardized tests compared to their public school counterparts—between 15 to 30 percent higher. They tend to be more successful in college, exhibit lower levels of anxiety and depression, and benefit from enhanced social development through civic engagement and strong family values. For instance, homeschoolers outshine public school students on the SAT, averaging 1190 compared to 1060. A significant 78 percent of peer-reviewed studies have confirmed that homeschoolers achieve better academic results consistently.
Nevertheless, opposition to homeschooling remains intense. Detractors, primarily from liberal circles, voice concerns about the lack of oversight, potential limited exposure to diverse viewpoints, and fears that religious families may indoctrinate their children with “harmful” traditional values related to gender and sexuality. This resistance doesn’t just signify a difference in educational philosophy; it underscores a fundamental conflict between parental rights and state authority. It raises the question of whether children should primarily be raised in families or by government institutions.
Statistics reveal that 41 percent of homeschooled students are nonwhite, debunking stereotypes about homeschooling being an exclusive option for privileged families. Research also shows that Black homeschoolers score impressively well, outpacing Black public school students by 23–42 percentile points. Additionally, homeschooled students excel in post-secondary education: 74 percent continue to college, a stark contrast to the 44 percent of traditional public school students. Their average GPA stands at 3.46, surpassing the 3.16 GPA of their peers from public schools.
The emotional health of homeschooled students appears to benefit significantly from the personalized support they receive. Parents can intervene immediately to address issues, providing an “emotional respite” that enhances students’ confidence and reduces anxiety. In fact, recent studies indicate that 87 percent of peer-reviewed research from 2021 to 2025 confirms homeschooled students exhibit superior social, emotional, and psychological development compared to their conventionally schooled peers.
Conversely, public schools are facing a mental health crisis. Reports show that 40 percent of high school students experienced persistent sadness or hopelessness in 2023. The demand for mental health support in schools has skyrocketed since the pandemic. As more than one in four students were chronically absent in the last school year due to mental health struggles, it becomes clear how homeschooling offers a more supportive environment.
For many families, especially Christian ones—comprising at least 70 percent of homeschooling households—the decision stems from a desire to instill religious and traditional values. Research indicates that homeschooled children are 51 percent more likely to attend religious services regularly as adults, compared to their peers who attended public school. This connection to faith extends beyond childhood; about 70 percent of adults from religious homeschooling backgrounds still engage in church services frequently.
Homeschooling also promotes healthier lifestyle choices. Adolescents in homeschooling environments report lower rates of depression and substance use. They engage in fewer risky behaviors, including having fewer lifetime sexual partners. The data reflects stronger character traits, with higher levels of forgiveness, purposefulness, and civic engagement. The involvement in extracurricular activities remains robust, with over 80 percent participating in activities outside the home, and they are more likely to engage in volunteering and other civic duties as adults.
Critics often dismiss positive outcomes, arguing that the studies are small-scale or self-selecting. However, despite these criticisms, no substantial evidence shows that homeschooling yields worse outcomes than public schooling. The fight against homeschooling isn’t merely a discussion about educational methods; it comes down to ideological control and the cultural power struggles surrounding family values.
The push for state-controlled education revolves around notions of enforced equity. Framed by proponents as a compassionate necessity, this approach often disrupts families’ rights to guide their children’s moral education. The psychological ramifications of seeing children educated under state-approved ideologies instead of family values reflect a larger ideological war between collectivist governance and individual rights.
At its heart, the controversy centers on parental rights. While critics may frame their opposition as a guardianship of children’s welfare and education, the underlying motive often reveals an impulse to monopolize control over what children learn and how they think. The notion of equitable education that dismisses the option of homeschooling conflicts with the constitutional rights of parents who want to instill their values in their own children. This ongoing debate will continue to shape the future of education in America.
"*" indicates required fields
