A recent court filing in Virginia raises questions about a Democratic candidate’s eligibility that could have significant implications for the upcoming House of Delegates elections. Three residents of Stafford County are challenging candidate Stacey Carroll’s residency, claiming she does not live in the district she seeks to represent. Their suit could sway control of the state chamber for 2026.
The plaintiffs—Stephen Schwartz, Judith Anne Parker, and Juliet Schweiter—contend that Carroll resides near US-1 in Aquia, Virginia, which lies within the Democratic-majority 23rd district. They argue that she falsely registered to run from an address closer to Stafford Court House, approximately seven miles away, in the 64th district. This discrepancy, if proven, could lead the court to invalidate her candidacy.
According to the Virginia Mercury, the address which Carroll claims as her home is reportedly registered to another family. A 1966 ruling by the Virginia Supreme Court places the onus of proof regarding residency on the individual registering to vote. If the court rules in favor of the plaintiffs, Carroll’s voter registration at the Stafford address could be thrown out, disqualifying her from the ballot.
The stakes of this dispute are high. Democrats have targeted all 100 House of Delegates seats for the 2026 elections, marking a rare commitment to contesting every seat, including traditionally Republican regions. If Carroll remains eligible, she will face Republican Delegate Paul Milde, who represents a district that previously tilled a narrow victory for President Trump in the 2024 election.
However, if Carroll is found to indeed reside in Aquia, she would have an easier path in a district held by Democratic Delegate Candi King of Prince William, which is far more favorable politically—it swung decisively for former Vice President Kamala Harris, garnering approximately 66% of the vote.
Control of the House of Delegates is significant. Following the 2023 elections, Democrats reclaimed the chamber and now hold a narrow 52-48 majority. A tie in the House would favor Republicans, requiring only three additional victories to retake control. Each seat in the chamber is crucial as Republicans also navigate tightly contested races in areas like Hampton Roads.
Del. A.C. Cordoza, the only Black Republican in the House, represents a district that Harris narrowly won. Republicans are determined to solidify their presence in these battlegrounds, with high-profile backing from state leaders focused on keeping competitive races under party control.
The potential impact of this court case extends beyond Carroll’s candidacy. Control of the House of Delegates and its possible dynamics could hinge on whether Carroll’s eligibility is upheld or challenged. The current political climate in Virginia showcases an aggressive effort by both parties to consolidate power, and any changes may alter their path moving forward.
As the debate unfolds, the local and statewide implications will resonate, influencing how both parties prepare for tight races in 2026. Whether or not Carroll appears on the ballot will set the stage for combat in races marked by political tensions and shifting allegiances in a state that has been a battleground for years.
"*" indicates required fields
