FBI Raids Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao’s Home in Confidentiality Probe
On June 20, 2024, Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao found herself in the middle of a federal investigation as FBI agents executed a raid at her home in the Oakland Hills. This raid was part of a broader operation targeting at least four other locations throughout the city, including the Vietnamese American Community Center of the East Bay (VACCEB). According to multiple sources familiar with the situation, the operation centers on allegations of public corruption.
By midday, the scene was bustling with activity. Agents were seen transporting boxes of evidence from Thao’s home, loading them into unmarked vehicles. FBI spokesperson Bennett O. Lacy confirmed the agency’s actions, describing them as “court-authorized law enforcement activity” but did not divulge information on the specifics of the investigation. However, whispers around the operation suggest it likely revolves around political corruption, misappropriated public funds, and questionable relationships between public officials and nonprofits receiving financial support from the city.
As the federal investigation unfolds, the mayor remains neither arrested nor charged with any crime. Her office has not issued a statement regarding these events, and attempts to contact her communications team have gone unanswered. Thao, who became the first Hmong American mayor of a major U.S. city in 2022, is already facing a recall effort. Supporters of the recall have voiced concerns about her handling of city finances, rising crime rates, and transparency issues at City Hall.
Among the locations targeted in the raids, the Vietnamese American Community Center of the East Bay stands out. Situated in a building owned by the Unity Council, a nonprofit organization that manages neighborhood improvement and economic initiatives in the Fruitvale district, the center receives financial assistance from both the city and federal government. Executive Director Andrew Doan confirmed the raid but did not provide details on what agents were looking for, simply stating, “We’re cooperating with the authorities.”
Public records reveal that VACCEB received substantial grants from the City of Oakland and federal pandemic relief programs, amounting to hundreds of thousands of dollars in recent years. In 2022 alone, the center was allocated over $500,000 for critical services, including elder care, food relief, and mental health assistance, all financed through city agencies and discretionary funds tied to the mayor’s office.
Concerns about oversight regarding financial control at nonprofits have been circulating within city discussions for over a year. A city official, speaking on condition of anonymity, stated, “There’s been zero transparency into how that money was distributed and whether it helped the people it was meant to serve.”
With at least five locations implicated in the Thursday raids, the U.S. Attorney’s Office in the Northern District of California has yet to release any indictments. Legal experts suggest the well-coordinated operation points to a considerable, likely protracted investigation. Professor Rory Little, an authority on law, noted, “This isn’t an ad hoc warrant. They executed simultaneous raids, which means they are either consolidating evidence or anticipating charges against multiple targets.”
The timing of this scandal burdens the Thao administration further. Oakland has experienced a surge in violent crime since 2019, with 120 homicides reported in 2023 alone—a 14% increase from the previous year. The first five months of 2024 have shown a staggering 35% rise in robberies compared to the same timeframe in 2023. This alarming trend, paired with significant business closures in downtown and Chinatown, has stoked public frustration. An effort to recall Mayor Thao gained momentum, gathering over 29,000 signatures in under three months, eclipsing the 25,000 threshold necessary to initiate a special election.
The federal investigation adds heavy scrutiny on an already beleaguered mayor. Thao ascended to office with promises of police reform and enhanced tenant protections while vowing to expand social services. Much of her administration’s funding, aimed at community-based violence prevention and mental health programs, has flowed through partnerships with nonprofits now under scrutiny. Questions about financial responsibility are proliferating even among her progressive supporters, raising concerns that ideology may have clouded sound fiscal judgment.
Oakland’s city charter grants significant discretion to its mayor regarding funding allocations through budget proposals and emergency distributions. Though internal auditing systems are theoretically in place, complaints about inadequate resources and enforcement have persisted. The last comprehensive audit concerning nonprofit partners took place in 2020, just before the pandemic disrupted oversight functions across various city departments.
For years, law enforcement officials and municipal watchdogs have sounded alarms about potential misuse of crisis funds. The COVID-19 pandemic prompted an influx of federal and state funds directly allocated to local governments. A report from the U.S. Office of the Inspector General in 2023 discovered that approximately 5% of aid provided through programs like the CARES Act and American Rescue Plan lacked proper documentation or demonstrated signs of mismanagement.
Nelson Linder, the former Inspector General for San Francisco, detailed the inherent risks: “When you’re under the gun to move money fast during a crisis, it creates a flush period for fraud and favoritism. Most cities weren’t equipped to vet every subgrant and contractor.”
As the investigation evolves, the City Council largely remains quiet, withholding comments until more is known. However, one council member, speaking confidentially with local media, shared thoughts that the investigation “could blow the top off spending practices going back years.”
Community reactions reveal a split sentiment. While some kin of the mayor raise alarms about due process and potential political motivations behind the federal actions, others express relief that oversight may finally be enforced. East Oakland resident Teresa Nguyen, whose family has benefited from VACCEB programs, emphasized the need for accountability: “We just want to make sure the money’s really going to elders and folks who need it. If something’s wrong, we deserve to know.”
As of now, no court documents related to the investigation have been made public, and the FBI remains tight-lipped on whether further arrests or search warrants are forthcoming. The City Attorney’s Office has declined to comment, citing the open nature of the investigation.
This situation marks a significant moment in Oakland’s ongoing challenges regarding governance, public trust, and accountability. Regardless of the outcome of the federal probe, the political ramifications are already unfolding. One veteran city employee noted, “Even before this, people had stopped trusting decisions coming out of the mayor’s office. Now that doubt’s going to be harder to shake.”
"*" indicates required fields
