Jay Feely’s congressional run in Arizona’s 5th District has raised eyebrows among voters who follow his political history. The former NFL kicker is positioning himself as the choice for Donald Trump’s supporters, yet his past actions suggest a different story. Feely, who played for the Arizona Cardinals and wrapped up his career with the Chicago Bears, is now seeking to fill the seat currently held by Rep. Andy Biggs, who plans to run for governor in 2026.
Many are scrutinizing Feely’s claims of loyalty to the MAGA movement. He has a history of vocal criticism directed at Trump, which adds to the skepticism. According to reports, Feely has received backing from moderate Republicans, including Rep. Tom Emmer, Rep. Richard Hudson, and Rep. Juan Ciscomani. These figures aim to replace Biggs with a candidate who represents a less hardline approach. The Post Millennial notes that if Feely were to solidify support from these PACs, he might need an endorsement from Trump himself to secure the seat.
Feely’s campaign messaging stands in stark contrast to his previous endorsements and statements about the Trump presidency. Back in 2016, when the Republican primary heated up, he supported candidates like Jeb Bush, John Kasich, and Marco Rubio. As Trump emerged as the GOP nominee, Feely expressed disappointment with the direction of the party. Describing the 2020 debate between Trump and Biden as “painful to watch,” he later remarked that he wasn’t proud of any of the candidates.
His approach goes beyond mere political disappointment. Feely has shown admiration for Democratic figures, particularly Barack Obama and Bill Clinton. During Obama’s final year in office, he described the president as “the best orator we have had in the Oval Office.” Pictures with Clinton have circulated, further complicating his attempt to align with Trump’s base.
Feely has not shied away from controversial topics. Recently, he condemned supporters of Trump regarding the Capitol riots of January 6, labeling it “a failure in leadership.” This critique drew scrutiny, especially for his failure to address circumstances involving leftist instigators or the inadequate response from law enforcement. Such remarks might alienate the very voters he seeks to attract, as they look for candidates who defend Trump rather than critique him.
Additionally, Feely’s commentary on mail-in voting is noteworthy. He claimed that Republicans who utilize mail-in ballots are often more “educated,” which could come across as dismissive to traditional voters. His stance clashes with a growing sentiment among Republican leaders, including Trump, who advocate for stricter voting measures.
As the political landscape shifts, Feely’s campaign is precarious. He’ll need to reconcile his past statements with his future goals. If he hopes to resonate with the Trump base, he may have to make more than just a rhetorical pivot; he’ll need to show genuine alignment with their values and priorities. The election landscape in Arizona is competitive, and voters are paying close attention. This congressional race has implications that reach beyond mere party affiliation—it’s about trust, authenticity, and the ability to reflect the views of constituents.
"*" indicates required fields
