Cincinnati finds itself in the eye of a storm as Police Chief Teresa Theetge is placed on paid administrative leave amid an internal investigation into her leadership. City Manager Sheryl Long’s decision, made in late May, reflects growing concerns about violent crime and management practices at the top tiers of the Cincinnati Police Department (CPD).
Theetge, the first female police chief in the city, was attending a professional conference when she was called back to be informed of her status. She has retained attorney Steve Imm, signaling her intention to defend her position publicly. This situation has sparked political tension and public outrage, especially following accusations on social media suggesting that her leave might stem from “anti-white behavior.” However, city officials have not validated such claims, focusing instead on “serious public safety challenges” as the core issue.
The complexity of the situation is amplified by its political ramifications. While some city council members express support for leadership changes, others voice frustration over the lack of discretion in handling Theetge’s leave. Councilman Mark Jeffreys stated, “She has earned the respect to not have her employment status played out in public,” while Jeff Cramerding echoed the call for clarity: “We just want to understand why.”
Cincinnati is grappling with rising crime rates, particularly in the downtown area, where a series of violent incidents, including a fatal shooting and a viral brawl, have raised questions about police effectiveness under Theetge’s command. The CPD suffers from chronic understaffing, with an estimated shortfall of 100 officers. The pressure on the department has never been greater, yet the leadership change carries significant implications.
The Fraternal Order of Police, the city’s police union, has publicly criticized city leadership’s actions. President Ken Kober expressed frustration, stating, “She’s our chief, and we feel that she’s getting railroaded.” This sentiment highlights a division between police leadership and city officials, indicating a possible struggle for control over how public safety is maintained.
In addition, the decision mirrors recent events in city management, with the previous Fire Chief Michael Washington being dismissed over similar issues tied to leadership culture. This trend raises questions about systemic challenges within city departments under the current administration.
The timing of Theetge’s leave is crucial. Historically, summer months escalate violent crime, and any leadership instability may further burden an already strained police force. While the city has initiated measures to boost officer recruitment and retention, fundamental issues remain, threatening to undermine their efforts. Despite a 10% decline in overall shootings, downtown disorder and property crimes have risen by over 15%, casting a shadow on public safety initiatives.
Theetge’s own remarks before her leave underscored the challenges facing the city. She stated, “We need to make downtown a safer place for businesses,” revealing an understanding of the nexus between public safety and community trust.
As Interim Chief Adam Hennie steps in to navigate this precarious landscape, he inherits a department at a crossroads. The pressure is mounting to restore public faith and address violent crime, placing him and city leadership under scrutiny.
The forthcoming internal investigation will play a pivotal role in determining Theetge’s future. Whether she returns or not, the implications of this leadership shake-up are far-reaching, and the discourse around crime and accountability in Cincinnati remains heated. The stakes are high, with the potential for political fallout looming as the city grapples with its safety strategy in the face of uncertainty.
"*" indicates required fields
