California Governor Gavin Newsom’s latest attempt to undermine Vice President JD Vance has drawn much attention and criticism. Many suggest that, instead of damaging Vance’s reputation, the move has inadvertently boosted it. The video shared on Newsom’s official page sought to draw parallels between Vance and former President Donald Trump, yet it seems to have highlighted qualities that resonate well with voters.
The clip quickly garnered traction on X (formerly Twitter), where viewers swiftly turned the narrative on its head. One tweet put it bluntly: “🚨 JUST IN: The official Gavin Newsom page posted this video of 48, JD Vance, and MAGA is mocking Gavin for only helping JD become more likable. This is supposed to be an attack?” Such reactions illustrate a broader trend. Instead of fostering disdain for Vance, many perceive the video as an unintentional nod to his appeal.
At its core, the video seems to mimic Trump’s distinctive style—short, aggressive bursts of criticism infused with personal jabs. Newsom had previously employed a similar technique, using exaggerated formats to mock Trump. However, this foray into satire targeting Vance appears poorly executed and lackluster, overshadowed by Vance’s confident and coherent demeanor.
In a recent interview, Vance provided commentary on the ongoing tussle with Newsom, suggesting that the governor should “stop sounding like crazy people.” Vance emphasized the natural appeal of Trump’s communication style, regarding it as genuine and effective. “The genius of Trump’s political success was that he’s authentic,” Vance noted, a statement that rang particularly true in this context. He cleverly proposed, “So does that make him authentically crazy if Newsom is just following his lead?” This remark, while playful, bolstered Vance’s point: authenticity resonates with voters more than imitation.
Political analyst John Burke offered insight into this unfolding drama. He stated, “Newsom is trying to rebrand Trumpism as madness by copying it in an exaggerated way. The problem is, when you do that with someone like JD Vance, who presents with confidence and coherence, you just amplify his status.” Burke’s observation underscores Newsom’s miscalculated approach, where his intended ridicule might instead elevate the subject of ridicule.
This isn’t Newsom’s first venture into using satire against Republicans on social media. Previous efforts to mock Trump received criticism for their lack of seriousness. Fox News anchor Dana Perino pointed out, “He’s got a big job as governor of California but if he wants an even bigger job he has to be a little more serious.” This sentiment carries over to the current situation; the mockery may inadvertently convey the opposite of what was intended.
JD Vance has emerged as part of a new breed of conservatives who are gaining traction nationally. A former venture capitalist and bestselling author, Vance blends intellectual rigor with a populist message. His involvement in recent messaging efforts blends policy with cultural issues, appealing both to Trump’s base and to independents. This approach underscores both a strategic calculation and a growing influence within the party.
Polling data supports the effectiveness of this approach. Recent surveys reveal an uptick in Republican approval ratings, particularly among working-class voters in swing states. Many have indicated that qualities like “authenticity” and “plain talk” are essential in leadership. One recent YouGov poll reported that 59% of Republican-leaning voters found Vance “more relatable” than other GOP figures—a considerable rise from earlier in the year.
In light of this data, Newsom’s attempted mockery may have backfired, inadvertently adding to Vance’s momentum. Political consultant Alan Twomey encapsulated this dynamic succinctly: “When you attack someone using their own successful communication model—and you’re inauthentic doing it—you’re not hurting them. You’re just confirming to their audience that the model works.”
Responses on social media echoed this sentiment. One user commented, “He’s not mimicking. He is MOCKING. That you don’t understand demonstrates its effectiveness.” Another drew a clear distinction, interpreting Vance’s remarks as a signal of strategic clarity, posting, “According to JD Vance, Trump’s ‘authentic genius’ is the model to follow. Translation: be authentically unhinged.”
This clash over communication styles may signal a pivotal moment for political messaging as the 2024 election cycle heats up. Democrats are increasingly relying on satire and digital formats to engage younger audiences, yet the effectiveness of such tactics remains uncertain. In contrast, Republicans like Vance are focused on direct messaging that channels Trump’s instinctive style while integrating substantive policy ideas.
On the policy front, Vance emphasizes domestic manufacturing, energy independence, and parental rights—all key areas that resonate with middle-income voters. If Newsom intended to curb Vance’s ascent, the strategy seems poised for failure, aligning Vance even further with voter segments crucial for Democrats to win back in battleground states.
As of now, Newsom’s team has not made any clarifications regarding the video, leaving questions about its intent unresolved. The consequences of this exchange ripple across party lines, highlighting the nuanced role of tone in political discourse. As the election season progresses, a critical challenge remains for both sides: discerning whether mockery is genuinely an effective strategy, especially when that mockery may occasionally translate into admiration.
"*" indicates required fields
