Public Outcry Over Property Tax Increases in Chicago
The outcry from Chicago residents over recent property tax hikes highlights a significant and growing crisis. Thousands of homeowners received bills that increased by over $1,000 compared to the previous year. This drastic rise has led some to protest by burning their tax bills in what they have termed a “property tax bonfire.” The intensity of the public anger is palpable, with many describing the increases as nothing short of “literal robbery.”
The frustration stems from a tax system perceived as increasingly unfair, benefiting developers and commercial property owners while placing a heavier burden on working families. Flawed property assessments have played a central role in this crisis. In 2023, more than 37,000 homes—particularly in the South and West Sides—saw assessed values surge, in some cases doubling or tripling. Neighborhoods like Englewood, Roseland, and North Lawndale experienced staggering increases between 119% and 160%, starkly contrasting with the citywide median increase of 22%.
Experts attribute the instability of the tax system to burdensome pension obligations and an inequitable appeals process that favors the affluent. An alarming 80% of Chicago’s property tax revenue is now directed to manage pension debt. Recent legislation has compounded this issue, as a new law signed by Governor J.B. Pritzker is anticipated to exacerbate pension liabilities by $11.1 billion.
Homeowners are voicing their despair. One expressed, “It’s a slow-motion disaster. Even if I did sell, where would I go?” This statement captures the tough choices many face in a market strained by skyrocketing taxes. Data from Cook County’s 35th Ward shows that 2,700 households paid an additional $8 million in property taxes last year. Disturbingly, over 1,000 homeowners—including 125 seniors—have lost their homes due to unpaid taxes, often over debts of less than $1,000.
The burden extends beyond individual families to commercial property owners, who have successfully appealed their property assessments. Following the 2024 reassessment cycle, commercial property owners in Cook County received significant reductions, cutting their assessed values and thereby shifting tax responsibilities even further onto residential homeowners. Before these appeals, homeowners were liable for approximately 49% of the city’s tax burden. Afterward, that figure rose to 54%.
The consequences of these manipulations are glaring. A study from the Cook County Treasurer found that successful appeals from commercial property owners added nearly $2 billion to homeowner tax bills over three years. Critics indicate that this is a flagrant abuse of the tax code that rewards insider dealings. Figures like former Illinois House Speaker Mike Madigan and ex-Chicago Alderman Ed Burke, previously implicated in corruption, profited by helping powerful clients evade their fair share of taxes.
Brian Costin, deputy state director of Americans for Prosperity–Illinois, voiced dissatisfaction with the current approach, stating, “Gov. Pritzker’s approach to economic development is upside down. Prosperity requires lower, simpler taxes for all—not special exemptions for the insiders.”
Compounding these concerns, Mayor Brandon Johnson has faced scrutiny tied to his financial task force’s recent proposals. Their interim report suggested automatic yearly property tax increases to counteract a forecasted $1.15 billion budget deficit. Jim Reynolds, co-chair of the task force, cautioned that failing to address the deficit could significantly harm city services. “If decisive action is not taken now,” he warned, “the consequences for city services—and for Chicago’s overall civic health—could be profound.”
Despite Johnson’s stance against outright property tax hikes, proposals to tie increases to inflation could lead to repeated tax rises without formal council votes, creating an automatic increase framework. This raises alarms about further destabilizing the real estate market, which is already showing signs of weakness amid high taxes and resident exodus from the state. Last year, Illinois lost 56,235 residents, many citing taxes as their primary reason for leaving.
In a striking indication of discontent, one resident compared their $10,000 property tax bill in Chicago to just $3,000 in similar housing in southwest Michigan. Such disparities amplify feelings of frustration and hopelessness among those remaining in the city.
Moreover, recent proposals, backed by Pritzker, suggest property tax abatements and freezes for large-scale developments, attracting critics who argue these moves will shift the tax burden further onto middle-class families. DuPage County Sheriff James Mendrick stated plainly, “This legislation pushed by Pritzker should be roundly rejected. The massive shift of the tax burden to residential homeowners…is corporate welfare on steroids.”
Adding to the complexity, Chicago’s Tax Increment Financing (TIF) program diverted a staggering $1.36 billion in property tax revenue in 2023—42% of total tax collections. Rather than enhancing public services, much of this funding benefits private interests and downtown development projects, leaving essential services, like sanitation and public safety, at risk.
The sentiment among residents is unmistakable and growing. The frustration, anger, and protests are tangible. For many homeowners, especially in struggling neighborhoods, the looming tax crisis feels existential. “Even if I did sell, where would I go?” This question echoes through the community as residents confront the harsh reality of rising bills with diminishing returns on city services.
"*" indicates required fields
