U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) reported a significant decrease in migrant encounters at the southern border in October 2023—particularly among Venezuelans. This drop is largely attributed to a return to strict enforcement tactics, which include resumed deportation flights and more stringent management of legal entry processes.
The statistics tell a clear story. Overall encounters at the southwest border fell by 11% from September to October, totaling 240,988. Notably, encounters with Venezuelan migrants plummeted by 65% after the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) reinstated direct removal flights to Venezuela on October 18, following an announcement on October 5. Since May, CBP reported that over 54,000 family members have been removed, totaling more than 355,000 migrants removed altogether.
Troy A. Miller, the acting CBP Commissioner, commented, “In conjunction with our resumption of removal flights to Venezuela, the number of Venezuelans encountered at the southwest border dropped significantly. These numbers speak to the necessity of strong enforcement policies.” His remark underscores the correlation between firm immigration measures and reduced migrant crossings.
The effectiveness of increased enforcement is further illustrated by additional CBP figures from October. Agents conducted 1,198 rescues of migrants in perilous situations, and drug interdiction teams seized 1,661 pounds of fentanyl. In fiscal year 2023, the total amount of fentanyl confiscated reached over 27,000 pounds, demonstrating a direct link between robust border enforcement and improved safety outcomes.
Improved coordination with Mexican authorities, enhanced technological applications, and intelligence-led operations like Operation Apollo and Operation Artemis are proving beneficial. These initiatives target transnational criminal organizations that traffic drugs and people across the border, showcasing a thorough approach to border security.
As pointed out by Craig Chamberlin, “Preventative measures like strict immigration policy” yield observable results. The data from October serves as validation that enforcement yields tangible outcomes.
The introduction of the CBP One™ mobile app has streamlined the management of lawful entries, allowing nearly 324,000 appointments to be scheduled by the end of October for migrants seeking legal entry. This program incentivizes adherence to legal protocols through its first-come, first-served model, adding another layer of structure to the border process.
Additionally, lawful parole programs have made significant strides, with 269,744 individuals from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua, and Venezuela entering through these processes by October. This initiative complements enforcement actions by offering controlled access routes for migrants seeking to enter legally.
Despite these advancements, enforcement remains critical. Recently, nearly 30,000 individuals were placed in expedited removal proceedings under Title 8 immigration law. Others faced Section 240 Removal Proceedings, ensuring that those with final removal orders will face mandatory repatriation to their home countries. Notably, Venezuela’s newfound willingness to accept deportation flights marks a significant turning point, enhancing enforcement efforts that had been lacking in the past.
Overall, the multi-faceted approach of timely deportations, increased lawful entry pathways, and stricter drug enforcement signals a return to deterrent-based strategies after years of fluctuating policies and mounting migrant numbers.
The practical implications of this strategy are manifest. With fewer migrants risking their lives in treacherous conditions and decreased chances for drug trafficking organizations to capitalize on disorder, the strategy appears effective.
This trend has also positively influenced trade and agriculture. In October, CBP processed $289 billion worth of imports, a 5.6% increase from the previous year. The agency further disrupted illicit supply chains by seizing goods tied to forced labor and counterfeit items. Enhanced agricultural protections followed suit with seizures of prohibited food products at ports of entry.
Troy Miller emphasized the role of enforcement in sustaining legitimate trade: “Every day, CBP officers, agents, and trade personnel are on the frontline enforcing our immigration laws, interdicting dangerous drugs, and facilitating lawful trade and travel.” His remarks underline the dual mission of ensuring security while supporting legal commerce.
The resurgence of deportation flights, particularly for nationalities that had previously evaded removal, is central to this success. For months, Venezuelans accounted for a significant share of unlawful crossings, and diplomatic barriers hampered removals. With flights back in service, deterrence can return effectively.
This situation is not merely an exercise in data analysis. It carries broader implications tied to ongoing legislative efforts. The Secure the Border Act of 2023, passed by the House in May, seeks to entrench many of these initiatives—expanding barriers, regulating parole discretion, enforcing employment verification, and streamlining deportations. Though it has yet to become law, its proposed measures reflect the successes observed in current enforcement practices.
For those prioritizing national security and adherence to the rule of law, the October data serves as compelling evidence that a straightforward enforcement strategy yields the best results. Policies focused on deterrence—prompt deportations, robust barriers, and interception of criminal enterprises—bring about the most effective behavioral changes.
With continued pressures such as the fentanyl crisis and humanitarian challenges, the realities at the border remain formidable. Yet, by closing the door to smugglers who may exploit vulnerabilities, the administration’s recent actions—though overdue—may help alleviate some of this pressure.
Moving forward, the clear takeaway is that effective immigration laws require not just writing but active enforcement. As demonstrated in October, practical application of these laws produces tangible results.
"*" indicates required fields
