The introduction of Thanksgiving as a national holiday by President Abraham Lincoln marked a significant turning point in American tradition. Originally, the end of November was reserved for Evacuation Day, a celebration steeped in patriotic history that commemorated the departure of British troops from New York City in 1783. Lincoln’s proclamation in 1863, which expressed gratitude for harvest blessings, gradually overshadowed this earlier observance, leading to Evacuation Day’s decline.
Evacuation Day symbolized a hard-fought victory for the new nation, as British presence lingered long after the Declaration of Independence. New York City, a British stronghold during the Revolutionary War, hosted captured soldiers on prison ships while serving as the center of British political activity. The city finally became free from British rule when the Treaty of Paris was signed, culminating in a ceremony on November 25, 1783. This date witnessed future President George Washington and New York Gov. George Clinton lead a military march down Broadway, celebrating the triumphant withdrawal of British troops.
The significance of the day was vividly illustrated when Sergeant John van Arsdale climbed a slick flagpole at Bennett Park to replace the Union Jack with the Stars and Stripes. This act of bravery became symbolic, showcasing Americans’ commitment to their newly established identity. The atmosphere was charged with excitement as 6,000 British soldiers set sail back to England, marking the day deeply in American memory.
The celebrations of Evacuation Day were grand and heartfelt. Washington’s farewell toast at Fraunces Tavern on that historic evening echoes through time. “With a heart full of love and gratitude, I now take leave of you,” Washington stated, wishing prosperity and happiness to the American people. Such sentiments highlighted the bond between the emergent nation and its leaders.
In the years that followed, Evacuation Day became an important occasion, often celebrated with formal dinners and parades, cementing its status in American culture. Schools recognized the holiday, and festive gatherings mirrored the vigor of American patriotism. Notably, high-profile establishments like the Plaza Hotel hosted grand dinners, and menus from the centennial celebration showcased the culinary customs of the time, featuring dishes like fish, pheasant, and turkey.
As the 20th century dawned, however, changing international relationships significantly impacted commemorations of Evacuation Day. Diplomatic relations between the United States and Great Britain grew warmer, especially with joint participation in two world wars. Consequently, the significance of Evacuation Day diminished, overshadowed by more contemporary national celebrations and Thanksgiving’s rise to prominence.
Yet, even as the modern focus shifted, pockets of remembrance for Evacuation Day remained alive. Events occasionally occurred, including flag-raising ceremonies and commemorative processions. In 2025, an anticipated 242nd anniversary procession from Fraunces Tavern to Evacuation Day Plaza suggests a renewed interest in this historic celebration is emerging.
These commemorative gestures remind Americans of their history, honoring the legacy left by early leaders like Washington. Thirteen toasts raised at Fraunces Tavern reflected the aspirations and gratitude of a fledgling nation. Each toast, recorded by an aide, celebrates unity, liberty, and the hope of safeguarding the hard-won rights of all citizens.
In recalling these events, the essence of Evacuation Day serves as a reminder of the foundational triumphs and sacrifices that paved the way for modern America. While Thanksgiving enjoys its status as a national holiday, understanding the roots and significance of Evacuation Day enriches the national narrative, honoring those who fought for freedom and sovereignty. Through these reflections, Americans can appreciate the full breadth of their holiday traditions, recognizing the historical context that shaped them.
"*" indicates required fields
